Visa and Mastercard each run their own program to watch merchants with too many disputes, and the two programs count different things, use different tiers and are enforced through different rules. A merchant can be comfortable under one brand and in trouble under the other, which is why one blended “chargeback ratio” for your whole account can mislead you. This guide explains what is publicly known about each program, where the counting differs, what that means for how you track your numbers, and which questions to put to your processor so you are not learning the difference from a warning letter.

The short answer

  • There are two separate programs. Visa runs its Acquirer Monitoring Program, called VAMP. Mastercard runs its Excessive Chargeback Program, with a separate program for excessive fraud.
  • Visa combines fraud reports and disputes into one ratio. Mastercard places merchants in tiers based on monthly chargeback thresholds, and handles fraud through a separate program.
  • Visa publishes its merchant-level numbers. Mastercard’s exact thresholds and counting rules sit in its Security Rules and Procedures manual, which your processor can confirm for you.
  • Your processor has its own line too, and it is usually the one that reaches you first.
  • Track each brand on its own. Do not assume that a tool or an exclusion that works for one brand works the same way for the other.
Six steps to track card-brand dispute numbers: count settled card-not-present transactions, count disputes and fraud reports, work out Visa's ratio, ask about Mastercard, compare with the last three months, and get your limit in writing.

Why there is more than one list

Card brands such as Visa and Mastercard write the rules for the payments that run on their networks. Each one decides for itself how to measure bad behavior, where to draw its lines and how to respond when a merchant crosses them. They do not share a single scorecard. A merchant is, in effect, graded twice, once by each brand, and the two grades come from different arithmetic.

It also helps to know who the programs are aimed at. Visa’s program is named for the acquirer, the bank that lets a business accept cards, because the acquirer is the party Visa holds responsible. The merchant is the one whose behavior produces the numbers, and the acquirer passes the consequences down through the merchant agreement. That is why your processor can contact you even when you are far below any line a card brand has published. In our guide to the chargeback ratio at which card networks start threatening an account, we describe three lines stacked on top of each other: your processor’s line, the network’s line for the acquirer and the network’s line for the merchant.

What Visa measures

Visa’s published merchant line in the United States is a VAMP ratio of 1.5 percent, counted on card-not-present fraud reports and disputes. It applies only once a merchant has at least 1,500 of them in a month. Before April 1, 2026, that merchant line was 2.2 percent. Card-not-present means the card was not physically presented, as with online and phone orders.

Visa also holds the acquirer to a lower line across its whole card-not-present portfolio: Above Standard at a VAMP ratio of 0.5 percent and Excessive at 0.7 percent, per Visa’s program summary. Visa applies the merchant-level line when the acquirer is not already Above Standard or Excessive.

The ratio itself is built like this. Take the count of fraud reports plus the count of disputes on card-not-present Visa transactions in a month, and divide by the count of settled card-not-present transactions that month. Three details matter.

  • It is a count, not a dollar figure. A ten-dollar dispute weighs exactly as much as a thousand-dollar one.
  • Fraud reports are included. These are the reports an issuing bank, the bank that issued the customer’s card, files when a cardholder says a purchase was not theirs. They count even if no dispute follows.
  • Some items are left out. Disputes resolved through pre-dispute solutions are excluded, and so are fraud reports that qualify for Compelling Evidence 3.0, a Visa rule that lets a merchant show that a disputed purchase matches the same customer’s earlier, undisputed purchases. Both exclusions depend on the timing of Visa’s monthly data pull, so a case resolved late in the month may still be counted.

Here is the worked example from that guide. An online store settles 20,000 Visa card-not-present transactions in a month, and its issuing banks file 120 fraud reports and 90 disputes. The ratio is 210 divided by 20,000, which is 1.05 percent. A store that counted only chargebacks would see 90 divided by 20,000, or 0.45 percent, and believe it was safe.

What Mastercard measures

Mastercard runs a parallel structure through its Excessive Chargeback Program. That program places merchants in an Excessive Chargeback Merchant tier, or in a higher High Excessive Chargeback Merchant tier, based on monthly chargeback thresholds. Alongside it, Mastercard has a separate program for excessive fraud.

This is the first real difference. On Visa, fraud reports and disputes land in one ratio. On Mastercard, chargebacks and fraud are handled by two programs, so a merchant has two things to watch rather than one.

The exact Mastercard thresholds and counting rules are not something we will quote here. They sit in Mastercard’s Security Rules and Procedures manual, they can change, and your processor can confirm the current figures that apply to your account. That is an honest limit on what a public guide can say, and it is also the reason to ask your processor for those numbers directly.

One more Mastercard item deserves a mention because it is the long-term consequence of a bad outcome. Mastercard maintains the MATCH list, which acquirers check on new applications. The bank or processor places a business on it, not Mastercard, and a record is kept for five years. We explain how a business ends up there in our guide to the MATCH list. Excessive chargebacks are one of the reasons a closure can lead to a listing.

Side by side: what we can and cannot say

Question Visa Mastercard
Name of the program Visa Acquirer Monitoring Program (VAMP) Excessive Chargeback Program, plus a separate program for excessive fraud
What is counted Card-not-present fraud reports plus disputes, divided by settled card-not-present transactions Monthly chargebacks, placed into tiers. Fraud is handled by the separate program.
Published merchant number 1.5 percent in the U.S. from April 1, 2026 (2.2 percent before), with at least 1,500 fraud reports and disputes in the month Not quoted here. See Mastercard’s Security Rules and Procedures manual, or ask your processor.
Acquirer-level line Above Standard at 0.5 percent, Excessive at 0.7 percent Ask your processor how the acquirer is measured.
Pre-dispute exclusion Disputes resolved through pre-dispute solutions are left out of the count Ask whether an equivalent exclusion applies. Do not assume it does.
Tiers Merchant line applies when the acquirer is not already Above Standard or Excessive Excessive Chargeback Merchant, then High Excessive Chargeback Merchant

Where the table says to ask, we mean it. A confident guess about another brand’s rules is the kind of mistake that costs a merchant a month of warning.

Why the difference matters for your account

If the two programs were the same, one number would do. Because they are not, a single combined figure hides the signal you need. Here are the practical consequences.

  • Your Visa and Mastercard mix can differ. If most of your customers pay with one brand, a problem in the smaller brand can be large in percentage terms and still look small in your overall total.
  • Different things can hurt you on each brand. Visa’s count includes fraud reports that never become disputes. A merchant who counts only chargebacks can look fine on Visa and still be over the line. Mastercard’s two-program structure means a merchant can be fine on chargebacks and still draw attention on fraud.
  • A fix for one brand may not carry over. On Visa’s published method, disputes resolved through a pre-dispute tool are excluded from the count. Rapid Dispute Resolution, a Visa program that lets a merchant refund a dispute before it becomes a chargeback, is the example NPS describes in its high-risk chargeback and VAMP guide. Before you plan around a similar benefit on Mastercard, ask your processor what applies there.
  • Winning a dispute does not undo the count. On Visa’s published method, a dispute is counted when it is filed, even if you win it later. That makes prevention worth more than appeals, and it is worth asking whether the same is true on Mastercard.
  • Minimums differ. Visa’s merchant line applies only above 1,500 fraud reports and disputes in a month. That minimum decides who Visa names. It does not decide who your processor acts on, because your contract applies at any volume.

How the pressure builds, whichever brand it comes from

Few merchants go from a healthy account to a closed one overnight. The pattern NPS sees is a staircase, and each step gives you less room than the last.

  1. Your processor notices. The first contact is often an email or a call asking what changed.
  2. You are asked for a plan. The processor wants the cause and what you are doing about it, often with refund policies, fulfillment records and fraud settings.
  3. Protection goes up. That can mean a reserve, delayed deposits, lower processing limits or a requirement to add fraud tools such as 3D Secure. A reserve is money held back to cover losses that may arrive later. We explain the idea in our guide on what reserve requirements to expect.
  4. A network identifies the account. If you cross a published line, the acquirer is notified, and it in turn requires remediation from you, with network fees and fines usually passed down under your merchant agreement. We do not quote fines here, because they are set by the networks and passed through differently from bank to bank.
  5. The account is closed. If the numbers do not come back down, the acquirer can end the account, and for certain reasons it can add the business and its owners to MATCH.

The steps are the same whether the pressure comes from Visa’s side or Mastercard’s. What changes is the measurement that triggers each step, which is why you want to see both.

How to track the two numbers monthly

A monthly routine that mirrors the network method takes less than an hour once it is set up. Do it separately for each brand.

  1. Pull the month’s settled card-not-present transactions by card brand, as a count, from your processor’s reporting.
  2. Pull every dispute and every fraud report for the same month, by brand. Fraud reports are often on a separate report, so ask your processor where to find them.
  3. For Visa, divide the count of disputes plus fraud reports by the count of settled card-not-present transactions.
  4. For Mastercard, ask your processor how its program counts your chargebacks and fraud, and track the number the way it does.
  5. Compare each result with the last three months. A rising trend matters more than any one month.
  6. Ask your processor what limit your agreement uses. That is the line that actually governs your account, and it is worth having in writing.

What helps on both brands

The levers that move your numbers are mostly the same for both brands, because they act on why customers dispute in the first place. Disputes and fraud reports come from a few places, and each has a different fix.

  • True fraud. Address verification, CVV checks, velocity limits and 3D Secure on riskier orders cut stolen-card use at the source. Watch for card testing, where criminals run many small authorizations to check stolen numbers.
  • Friendly fraud and buyer confusion. A billing descriptor that matches the name on your website, a clear renewal reminder, an easy cancellation path and a phone number that a person answers prevent more disputes than any appeal wins back. Our guide to subscription and free-trial chargebacks covers this in detail.
  • Problems with the order itself. Late shipping, items that do not match the description and refunds that never arrived all turn into disputes. These are the cheapest to prevent.
  • Refunding before a dispute. Pre-dispute tools protect Visa’s published number directly. They are not free and do not fit every business, so ask which brands your provider’s tools cover.

The brands also have their own chargeback reason codes, the labels that say why a dispute was filed. Our complete guide to chargebacks lists the common Visa and Mastercard categories and who decides each case.

Questions to ask your processor

If you remember only one section, make it this one. Ask for the answers in writing.

  1. Which monitoring programs apply to my account, for Visa and for Mastercard?
  2. What are the current thresholds and counting rules for each program as they apply to me?
  3. What limit does my own merchant agreement use, and is it stricter than the network’s?
  4. Do you report my Visa and Mastercard numbers separately, and where do fraud reports appear?
  5. Which of your dispute-prevention tools exclude a case from the count, and for which brand?
  6. What happens at each step if my ratio rises: who contacts me, what do you ask for and when would a reserve or limit apply?
Three questions and short answers on whether fraud reports count on Visa's ratio, whether exclusions carry over to Mastercard, and why to track each brand separately.

Who wrote this, and where NPS fits

Nationwide Payment Systems publishes this guide. We are a payment processing company in South Florida, in business since 2001, and a large part of our work is with high-risk and high-volume merchants, so dispute ratios are a daily conversation for us. The Visa figures here come from Visa’s own published program summary as we describe it in our related guide. Card networks revise these programs, sometimes more than once a year, and your processor’s contract can set stricter limits than either brand does, so confirm the current numbers before you plan around them. We do not quote fines, and we do not quote Mastercard thresholds that we cannot verify. You can find more in our payments guides library.

Our work usually starts before a problem shows up. We review your website for compliance gaps, help structure refund and cancellation disclosures, help set up Rapid Dispute Resolution when it fits, provide chargeback alert tools and coordinate with our banking partners early. Accounts come with live, U.S.-based support around the clock and a dedicated account manager.

We may not be the right choice if you want someone to promise a ratio will not trigger a review, because nobody can promise that. We underwrite each account, so we are not an instant-approval product. And tools can buy time, but they cannot fix a product or practice that customers keep disputing.

Checklist of six questions to ask a processor about Visa and Mastercard monitoring programs, thresholds, merchant agreement limits, separate reporting, exclusion tools and what happens if a ratio rises.

Bottom line

Visa and Mastercard do not keep one shared list. Visa counts card-not-present fraud reports and disputes in a single published ratio, and Mastercard sorts merchants into chargeback tiers with a separate fraud program. Your processor adds a third line of its own. Track each brand separately, do not assume an exclusion on one applies to the other, and get your processor’s limits in writing. If you would like a second opinion on your dispute numbers or a processing statement, you can talk with our team.

Frequently asked questions

Are Visa and Mastercard monitoring programs the same?

No. Visa runs its Acquirer Monitoring Program, which combines card-not-present fraud reports and disputes into one ratio. Mastercard runs its Excessive Chargeback Program, which places merchants in tiers based on monthly chargeback thresholds, alongside a separate program for excessive fraud.

What is Visa’s merchant-level line?

Visa’s published line for a single merchant in the United States is a VAMP ratio of 1.5 percent from April 1, 2026, and it was 2.2 percent before that. It applies only when the merchant has at least 1,500 fraud reports and disputes in the month. Visa revises these programs, so confirm the current figure with your processor.

What are Mastercard’s thresholds?

Mastercard places merchants in an Excessive Chargeback Merchant tier or a higher High Excessive Chargeback Merchant tier based on monthly chargeback thresholds. The exact figures and counting rules are in Mastercard’s Security Rules and Procedures manual and can change, so ask your processor for the current numbers that apply to your account.

Do fraud reports count even if the customer never files a chargeback?

On Visa’s ratio, yes. The count includes fraud reports filed by issuing banks as well as disputes. That is why a merchant who counts only chargebacks often sees a lower number than Visa does.

Does a tool that keeps disputes out of Visa’s count work for Mastercard too?

Do not assume so. Visa leaves out disputes resolved through pre-dispute solutions. Whether and how a similar exclusion applies to Mastercard is a question for your processor, and you should get the answer in writing.

Why did my processor contact me when I am below the card brands’ published lines?

Your acquiring bank is held to a lower line across its whole portfolio, and your merchant agreement can set its own limits. Processors usually act early so their portfolio never reaches the network lines.

Should I track Visa and Mastercard numbers separately?

Yes. The programs count different things and use different tiers, so one blended figure can hide a problem on one brand. Track each brand monthly, compare against the last three months and ask your processor which limit governs your account.