There is no single cheapest way for a church or charity to accept card donations, because the answer depends on how your gifts arrive and how large each gift is. A gift can come through a website form, a monthly card on file, a tap at an event table, a card number read over the phone or a payment link in a message. Ask each processor whether it prices those paths differently. The cheapest setup is the one that leaves the most money in your bank account on your own mix of gifts, and you find it by sorting a recent statement into those paths and pricing each one. This guide shows the method with made-up numbers, the fee lines Stripe and Square publish and the questions to put to any processor before you sign.

Compare processors on what lands in your account, not on a headline rate

This guide does not try to say what a church or charity should be offered. It shows how to compare any two offers using the gifts your organization actually receives.

Start with one number: the amount that reaches your bank for each gift. On a $100 gift, ask what amount reaches your bank and how your system shows the fee. The useful measure is the net you receive, and the useful comparison is net received across the same set of gifts under each quote.

A headline rate such as “2.9% + 30 cents” does not say what happens to a $15 gift, a $5,000 gift, a gift keyed in by a volunteer or a gift that repeats every month. If you take gifts in several ways, you need each line and your own counts.

The rest of this guide is a working method: sort a month of gifts, price each path on published lines, check how fixed cents behave on small gifts, ask about gifts that are not simple one-time payments, and run any pass-through quote through the same table.

See also NPS’s page titled The Merchant’s Guide to What You Really Pay for Card Processing.

See also NPS’s page titled Do Nonprofits Pay the Same Card Processing Rates as For-Profit Businesses?

See also NPS’s page titled Card-Testing Attacks on Donation Forms: Why Nonprofits Get Targeted and Where the Exposure Sits.

Sort a month of gifts by path and by size

Pull your most recent processing statement, or an export from your donation software, and sort the month into the paths your organization actually uses. Go through this list and keep the ones that apply:

  • Online, one time: a donor types a card number into a form on your website or follows a payment link.
  • Card on file: a saved card is charged again on a schedule or on request.
  • Tap, dip or swipe: a donor pays at a reader, for example at a table or a counter.
  • Keyed: someone on your team types a card number that a donor gave in person or by phone.
  • Invoice or pledge reminder: you send a bill or a link and the donor pays from the message.

You may use one of these or all five. For each path, write down two numbers: the total dollars and the number of gifts. You need both, because the published lines in the next section are a percentage plus cents per payment. A table with five rows and those two columns is enough to price every quote you receive.

Then add a size cut. Split each path into small, middle and large gifts, using the same breaks for every quote. If you cannot tell which path a gift used, treat that as a finding and ask your processor or donation software to label them.

Here is a made-up month to show the method. It is not a statement about any real church or charity and it is not a promise about any account. Say an organization receives $12,500 in a month across 260 gifts, and pays the Square lines quoted in the next section:

  • 150 online gifts totaling $7,500, which is an average of $50: $247.50 + $45.00 = $292.50.
  • 60 card-on-file gifts totaling $1,800, which is an average of $30: $63.00 + $9.00 = $72.00.
  • 40 tap gifts totaling $2,000, which is an average of $50: $52.00 + $6.00 = $58.00.
  • 10 keyed gifts totaling $1,200, which is an average of $120: $42.00 + $1.50 = $43.50.

The fees add up to $466.00, which is about 3.7% of the $12,500, and the organization keeps $12,034.00. Over twelve months of the same mix, the fees would be $5,592.00. This is our arithmetic, checked with a calculator script, and the numbers are invented to show the method.

Made-up month example

What one invented month of gifts costs

  • 260 gifts, $12,500$466.00Total fees (~3.7% of $12,500)Organization keeps $12,034.00; over twelve months of the same mix, fees would be $5,592.00
Numbers are invented to show the method, not a promise about any account.

Look at where the dollars and the fees sit. The online path holds 60% of the dollars and about 63% of the fees. The card-on-file path holds about 14% of the dollars and about 15% of the fees. Tap gifts hold 16% of the dollars and about 12% of the fees. The keyed path holds about 10% of the dollars and about 9% of the fees. Your own table will show where your dollars and fees sit, which is why you sort before you shop.

Price each path on the processor’s own published lines

Fee figures should come from each processor’s own page, with the date you read it. As read on Square’s fees page on November 13, 2026, Square lists 2.6% + 15 cents for tap, dip or swipe, 3.3% + 30 cents for online sales or invoices, and 3.5% + 15 cents for manual entry or card on file. As read on Stripe’s pricing page on November 13, 2026, Stripe lists 2.9% + 30 cents per successful domestic card transaction, 0.4% per paid invoice for Invoicing, and an extra 0.5% for manually entered cards. Open each company’s own page for today’s figures before you rely on these.

Now price the same gifts on those lines. This is made-up math to show the method, not a promise and not a price list for any church or charity:

  • A $20 gift on Stripe’s line: 2.9% + 30 cents costs $0.88, so you receive $19.12.
  • A $1,000 gift on Stripe’s line: the same line costs $29.30.
  • A $20 gift on Square’s lines: online costs $0.96, so you receive $19.04, and tap costs $0.67, so you receive $19.33. A $1,000 gift costs $33.30 online and $26.15 by tap.

These lines are shown one processor at a time. We do not set Stripe’s line against Square’s, because the two pages name different payment types.

Notice how the share of the gift changes with its size. On Stripe’s line, the $20 gift loses 4.4% to fees and the $1,000 gift loses 2.93%. The fixed 30 cents is the reason. It is a bigger slice of a small gift than of a large one.

Next, a like-for-like check, one online payment against another online payment. Take the 150 online gifts from the made-up month, which total $7,500. On Square’s online line of 3.3% + 30 cents the fees are $247.50 + $45.00 = $292.50. Now compare an invented online quote, Y, at 2.5% + 45 cents, made up only to show the method. On the same gifts, Y costs $187.50 + $67.50 = $255.00. The gap is $37.50 a month, or $450.00 over twelve months. Neither quote is a real offer.

Fixed cents and percentages trade off against each other, so the cheaper quote can change with the gift size. Using the same two online lines, a $20 gift costs $0.96 on Square’s line and $0.95 on invented quote Y. A $100 gift costs $3.60 on Square’s line and $2.95 on Y. The two cross at $18.75, where both cost about $0.92. The crossing point is the fixed-cent difference of 15 cents divided by the percentage difference of 0.8%. Do that division for any two quotes, then see which side of it your gifts sit on.

Gifts that repeat are a second place where fixed cents add up. In made-up math on Stripe’s line, twelve monthly gifts of $30 cost $1.17 each, which is $14.04 for the year, or about 3.9% of the $360. One gift of $360 would cost $10.74, or about 2.98%. The $3.30 gap is twelve fixed fees against one. If you collect gifts on a schedule, ask each processor whether every charge carries its own per-payment fee, and multiply by how often it happens.

The figures above cover only Stripe and Square. We state no figures for other names, including PayPal, Clover, Toast, Helcim and QuickBooks Payments. Read each company’s own pricing page and use the same method.

See also NPS’s page titled Mobile Payment Processing for Small Businesses.

Ask what happens to gifts that are not simple one-time payments

Take these questions to each processor and ask for the answers in writing. We do not know how your organization takes gifts, so each is an if-then.

  • If you accept gifts by phone or at an event table, ask what the keyed price is and what the tap price is, and whether the two differ. Square’s page lists 3.5% + 15 cents for manual entry or card on file and 2.6% + 15 cents for tap, dip or swipe.
  • If you save donors’ cards for repeat gifts, ask what each repeat charge costs and whether a failed charge costs anything. Ask who is responsible for keeping the stored card details safe.
  • If a donor asks for a refund, ask whether the processing fee on the original gift comes back to you.
  • If a gift is disputed, ask what the dispute costs and whether it is returned when you win. Stripe’s pricing page, as read on November 13, 2026, lists $15.00 for each dispute received, $15.00 for each dispute you respond to manually (refunded for won disputes) and $15.00 for each dispute appealed (not refunded). In our arithmetic, a dispute that is received and that you respond to manually costs $15.00 + $15.00 = $30.00 before any refund, so two such disputes cost $60.00 before any refund.
  • If someone on your team splits a larger gift into parts, ask whether each part carries its own fixed fee. In made-up math on Stripe’s line, a $200 gift costs $6.10 as one payment and $6.40 as two payments of $100, so the extra 30 cents is one more fixed fee.
  • If your donation form is open to the public, ask what controls the processor offers for suspicious attempts and what a flagged attempt costs.

Two more questions are about the contract. Ask whether there is a monthly minimum, a statement fee, a PCI fee, an equipment fee or an early termination fee, and ask for a sample statement that shows every fee on its own line. A fee you cannot see on its own line is one you cannot compare.

Before you sign

Questions to ask every processor in writing

  • Ask what the keyed price and tap price are, and whether the two differ
  • Ask what each repeat charge costs and whether a failed charge costs anything
  • Ask whether the processing fee on the original gift comes back to you if a donor asks for a refund
  • Ask what a dispute costs and whether the fee is returned when you win
  • Ask whether there is a monthly minimum, a statement fee, a PCI fee, an equipment fee or an early termination fee
  • Ask for a sample statement that shows every fee on its own line

See also NPS’s page titled The Hidden Credit Card Processing Fees Draining Your Business (How to Stop Them Today).

Where interchange pass-through fits, and what it does not settle

NPS offers interchange pass-through pricing next to flat-rate options. NPS sells pass-through, so we are not neutral on this question. Treat this section as a question to put to any processor, not proof of savings. If you receive a pass-through quote, ask what the markup is, ask for it in writing and ask which add-on fees come with it. A quote you cannot put into your table is a quote you cannot compare.

The study we cite, “The Flat-Rate Tax” (2026 Edition), was written by Allen Kopelman, the CEO of NPS. It is a model built from published rate schedules, not a survey of merchants. Here is what it found, and no more. In the model, interchange pass-through costs 19% to 31% less than flat rate for online and invoice sales across average tickets of $15 to $2,500. One example from it is a business with $50,000 a month in invoices at a $150 average ticket, which keeps about $6,100 a year. Those figures are for online and invoice sales in the model, and the $6,100 example is an invoice example, not a donation example. You can read the study as NPS’s 2026 pricing study. Test any quote against your own statement.

The study also shows where flat rate can still win. In the model, flat rate can win for very small tickets, around $15 and under in person, and for brand-new, very low-volume businesses. If your organization is brand new or receives very few gifts, price a flat-rate option alongside any other quote. If a large share of your gifts are small, price those small gifts on their own line before you decide either way.

Three details affect any comparison, and each one is a question for your processor:

  • Debit cards: large-bank debit is capped at 0.05% + 21 cents, plus a 1 cent fraud adjustment. The cap does not apply to small-bank debit. Ask how your processor treats the debit cards in your own gifts.
  • Business and commercial cards: they can cost more. If a company gives to your organization by card, ask how those gifts are priced.
  • Level 2 and Level 3 data: Level 2 and Level 3 data can lower interchange. If you take gifts from companies, ask whether your system can pass that data.

See also NPS’s page titled Level 2 and Level 3 Processing: Lower B2B Interchange Rates.

Bottom line

The cheapest way for a church or charity to accept card donations is the setup with the most net received on your own mix of gifts, and no advertised rate can tell you that in advance. Sort a recent statement into online, card-on-file, tap, keyed and invoice gifts, and by gift size. Price each path using the processor’s own published lines, including the fixed cents and the dispute fees. Ask every processor the same written questions about repeat gifts, refunds, disputes and split gifts. Then compare the totals, and ask which quote leaves the most in your account.

You can also run your own numbers through our savings calculator.

Who wrote this, and where NPS fits

Nationwide Payment Systems (NPS) publishes this guide. We are based in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, in business since 2001, and we sell merchant accounts and invoicing software, so we are not neutral. We offer interchange pass-through pricing, ACH, a payment gateway and Smart Invoicing, and we also offer flat-rate options. We do not publish a price list. The study we cite was written by our CEO. NPS offers a free statement review.

Frequently asked questions

What is the cheapest way for a church or charity to accept card donations?

There is no fixed cheapest option, because it depends on how your gifts arrive and how large each gift is. The cheapest setup is the one that leaves the most net received on your own sorted statement. Price each path you use, such as online, card on file, tap and keyed, and compare written quotes line by line.

How do I compare two processors for donations?

Sort one month of gifts by path and by size, then price each row with each processor’s published lines and total the fees. Include monthly, statement, gateway, equipment and dispute lines in the total. The quote with the lower total on your own gifts leaves more in your account.

Do small gifts cost more as a share of the gift?

Yes, when a price includes a fixed amount per payment. In our arithmetic, using Stripe’s 2.9% + 30 cents as read on November 13, 2026, a $20 gift costs $0.88, which is 4.4%, and a $1,000 gift costs $29.30, which is 2.93%. That is made-up math to show the method, not a promise about your account.

Does it matter how a donor’s card is taken?

It can. As read on Square’s fees page on November 13, 2026, Square lists 2.6% + 15 cents for tap, dip or swipe and 3.5% + 15 cents for manual entry or card on file. Check each company’s own page for today’s prices.

Is interchange plus cheaper than flat rate for donations?

It can be for online and invoice payments in our study’s model, which finds 19% to 31% lower costs across average tickets of $15 to $2,500. It is a model from a processor that sells pass-through pricing, and its figures are for online and invoice sales, not gifts, so test any quote against your own statement. Flat rate can win for very small tickets and for brand-new, very low-volume businesses.

Do disputes cost extra?

They can. Stripe’s pricing page, as read on November 13, 2026, lists $15.00 for each dispute received, $15.00 for each dispute you respond to manually (refunded for won disputes) and $15.00 for each dispute appealed (not refunded). So a dispute that is received and answered manually is $30.00 before any refund. Ask any processor you are considering for its dispute fees in writing.

Does NPS offer a statement review?

Yes. NPS offers a free statement review.