If you take cards in a tasting room, sell online and charge a club, you may have several kinds of payment on one statement, and the cheapest card processing is the setup with the lowest total across them on your own numbers. This guide does not rank Square’s price lines against each other. It spends its words on the questions a recurring saved-card charge raises, a way to sort a month’s statement so each payment is counted once, one small made-up month priced on Square’s own line names, and what to ask about disputes on a club charge. It covers payment mechanics only.

Questions to put to a processor about a recurring saved-card charge

Give the club charge its own set of questions, separate from your tasting-room payments. Ask each processor the same ones, and ask for every answer in writing.

  • Failed charges: when a charge to a saved card is declined, does the attempt itself cost anything? Is there a separate fee for a decline, or only for a payment that goes through?
  • Retries: does the system try a declined card again on its own, or does someone on your team have to start each new attempt? What does each additional attempt cost, and how many attempts can one charge have?
  • Expired cards: when a member’s card expires or is replaced, what does it cost to update the saved card? Who does the updating, you or the member, and does the update trigger any fee?
  • Stored-card and monthly fees: is there a fee per stored card, a monthly fee for charging saved cards, or a gateway fee? Is each one monthly, per payment or one time?
  • Statement line: will the club charges show up as their own line on the statement, separate from your tasting-room and online payments? If not, how would you tell them apart?
  • Fee line: which price line covers a saved-card charge? Is it the same line for every charge, or does the first charge differ from the later ones?
  • Refunds: if you refund a club charge, are the processing fees returned to you? If you skip a member’s charge for a month, does anything appear on the statement?

Write the answers beside each other in one place, one column per processor. If a processor will not answer one of these in writing, note that beside its column.

If a quote gives you one rate for everything, ask which of your payment types it was written for. Then ask what the price is for each of the other types you take.

See NPS’s page: “The Hidden Credit Card Processing Fees Draining Your Business (And How to Stop Them Today)“.

Sorting a month’s statement so each payment is counted once

Use one full month and follow these steps in order.

  1. Write down the statement’s total payment count, total dollars processed and total fees for the month. Those three numbers are your control totals.
  2. Make one group for tasting-room payments taken by tap, dip or swipe.
  3. Make one group for online sales or invoices. If you also take payments through an online API, give those their own group.
  4. Make one group for saved-card charges, which Square labels manual entry or card on file.
  5. Make a last group called unsorted, and a separate row for refunds.
  6. Put every statement line in exactly one group. A line you cannot place goes to unsorted, never to two groups.
  7. Add the counts and dollars of all groups. They must equal the control totals from step 1. If they do not, a payment has been counted twice or missed.

Retries need care. If the statement shows a declined attempt and the successful attempt that followed as separate lines, count the member’s payment once, in the group for saved-card charges, and keep the declined attempt in a note beside it. Then ask the processor whether the declined attempt carried a fee. Here is an invented case: if a statement lists 96 saved-card lines and you know 6 of them are retries of 6 members whose first attempt failed, that is 90 payments from 90 members, with 6 extra lines to ask about.

Refunds get their own row, so no group’s count or dollars changes without you seeing it. Ask the processor whether a refunded payment’s fee comes back, and write the answer next to the row.

Sort Your Statement

Count each payment exactly once

  1. Write control totalsWrite down the statement’s total payment count, total dollars processed and total fees for the month.
  2. Group in-person paymentsMake one group for tasting-room payments taken by tap, dip or swipe.
  3. Group online paymentsMake one group for online sales or invoices, and give online API payments their own group.
  4. Group saved-card chargesMake one group for saved-card charges, which Square labels manual entry or card on file.
  5. Place every linePut every statement line in exactly one group; a line you cannot place goes to unsorted, never to two groups.
  6. Check the totalsAdd the counts and dollars of all groups.

Once every line has one home, divide the total fees you paid in the month by the total dollars processed in the same month, for each group and for the whole month. If your processor cannot tell you which of its price lines each group used, ask it to label them on the statement before you compare any quote.

See NPS’s page: “The Merchant’s Guide to What You Really Pay for Card Processing“.

One small made-up month on Square’s four line names

This guide does not compare Square’s lines against each other. See NPS’s page: “In-Person vs Online vs Invoice: Which Sales Channel Costs the Most to Process?“.

What this guide does is price one invented month, group by group, each on the one line named for it. As read on Square’s fees page (squareup.com/help/us/en/article/5068-square-fees-overview) on November 13, 2026, Square lists these four lines: 2.6% + 15 cents for tap, dip or swipe, 3.3% + 30 cents for online sales or invoices, 2.9% + 30 cents for online API, and 3.5% + 15 cents for manual entry or card on file. Check Square’s page for today’s figures. Everything below is made-up math to show the method, not a promise about your account and not a statement about any brewery, winery or taproom. We assume the club charges sit on the manual entry or card on file line. Whether yours do is the first question to put to a processor.

Square’s Four Rate Lines

What each payment type costs on Square

  • Tap, dip or swipe2.6% + 15¢In-person tap, dip or swipeAs read on Square’s fees page on November 13, 2026
  • Online sales or invoices3.3% + 30¢Online sales or invoicesOnline API is 2.9% + 30¢
  • Manual entry or card on file3.5% + 15¢Saved-card or manual entry (club charges)Check Square’s page for today’s figures
Check Square’s page for today’s figures; these were read on November 13, 2026.

Each count and amount is invented. Each fee below is the percentage of the amount plus the fixed cents (our arithmetic, in exact cents).

  • Tap, dip or swipe: 150 payments of $30. Each costs $0.78 + $0.15 = $0.93, so the group costs 150 x $0.93 = $139.50 on $4,500.00.
  • Online sales or invoices: 40 payments of $70. Each costs $2.31 + $0.30 = $2.61, so the group costs 40 x $2.61 = $104.40 on $2,800.00.
  • Online API: 25 payments of $80. Each costs $2.32 + $0.30 = $2.62, so the group costs 25 x $2.62 = $65.50 on $2,000.00.
  • Manual entry or card on file: 90 club charges of $60. Each costs $2.10 + $0.15 = $2.25, so the group costs 90 x $2.25 = $202.50 on $5,400.00.

Invented Month Example

Each payment group’s share of fees

Payment group Invented total processed Fees paid
Tap, dip or swipe $4,500.00 (150 payments) $139.50
Online sales or invoices $2,800.00 (40 payments) $104.40
Online API $2,000.00 (25 payments) $65.50
Manual entry or card on file $5,400.00 (90 charges) $202.50
Every count and amount is invented to show the method, not a promise about your account.

Now the control check from the sorting steps. The counts add to 150 + 40 + 25 + 90 = 305 payments. The dollars add to $4,500.00 + $2,800.00 + $2,000.00 + $5,400.00 = $14,700.00. The fees add to $139.50 + $104.40 + $65.50 + $202.50 = $511.90. Divide $511.90 by $14,700.00 and the month comes to 3.48% of the dollars processed, which is our arithmetic on invented numbers.

Look at what the sort lets you do. The 90 club charges are 30% of the invented payments (90 of 305 is 29.5%, about 30%) but $202.50 of the $511.90 in fees, which is 39.6%. That sentence is true only of the invented month, and the point is the method. When you sort your own statement, check whether any group carries a share of the fees that surprises you, and then ask which price line that group used.

If your tasting room takes payments on a phone or tablet reader, ask which of the processor’s price lines those payments use.

See NPS’s page: “Mobile Payment Processing for Small Businesses“.

Nothing in this month carries a decline, a retry, a card update or a dispute, because we state no rate for those items. They are the extra rows to add once the processor answers the questions in the first section. Each answer becomes a count times a price, and you add it to the month in the same way. If a quote covers only some of your payment types, ask for a price on each type it leaves out.

See NPS’s page: “Exploring Different Types of Payment Processing for Your Business“.

Disputes on a club charge: what to ask and what Stripe lists

If a member disputes a club charge, ask each processor what happens next. Put these questions to each one in writing:

  • When one member disputes a single club charge, is there a fee for receiving it, a fee for responding, and a fee for an appeal? Which are returned if you win?
  • If a member disputes several months of club charges together, is each month its own dispute with its own fees, or are they grouped?
  • What does the processor need from you to respond, in what form, and how long do you have to send it?
  • Does the processor tell you when a dispute is opened, and where does it appear on the statement?
  • If a member asks you to stop the charge and you refund it, can a dispute still be opened afterward?

Ask each processor where it lists its dispute fees. For disputes we read only Stripe’s page. Stripe’s pricing page, as read on November 13, 2026, lists $15.00 for each dispute received, $15.00 for each dispute you respond to manually (refunded for won disputes) and $15.00 for each dispute appealed (not refunded). In our arithmetic, one dispute that is received and answered manually costs $15 + $15 = $30 before any refund for a won dispute. On an invented $60 club charge, $30 is 50% of the charge. Three such disputes cost $90 before any refund. We do not compare Stripe with any other processor here, and we list no other Stripe line.

PayPal, Clover, Toast, Helcim and QuickBooks Payments are other names to look at. We state no figure for them, so read each one’s own pages and price your own amounts on what you find.

See NPS’s page: “Secure Payment Processing for Businesses: What Keeps Card Transactions Safe and What You Are Responsible For“.

What to count each month, and what the study says

Once the groups exist, keep the same count every month so any change shows up as a number. Write down:

  • the payment count and dollars in each group, checked against the control totals
  • saved-card charges attempted, charges that went through, and charges that were declined
  • retries run, and cards updated after an expiry or replacement
  • refunds and skipped club charges, as a separate row
  • disputes received, disputes you answered and disputes you won
  • every fixed fee on the statement, marked as monthly, per payment or one time
  • total fees divided by total dollars processed, for each group and for the month

Keep three months of those rows, then run each quote’s price lines over your own counts and compare the totals.

Monthly Club Tracking

What to count every month for a club

  • Payment count and dollars in each group, checked against control totals
  • Saved-card charges attempted, charges that went through, and charges that were declined
  • Retries run, and cards updated after an expiry or replacement
  • Refunds and skipped club charges, as a separate row
  • Disputes received, disputes you answered and disputes you won
  • Total fees divided by total dollars processed, for each group and for the month

If a processor quotes interchange pass-through, ask what the markup is, whether it is written in the agreement and whether it is fixed. Ask whether the same markup applies to every payment type you take or whether each has its own. NPS sells pass-through, so we are not neutral on this question. Treat the study as one model to check against your own statement, not as proof of savings.

The study we cite, “The Flat-Rate Tax” (2026 Edition), was written by Allen Kopelman, the CEO of NPS. It is a cost model built from published rate schedules, not a survey. In the model, interchange pass-through costs 19% to 31% less than flat rate for online and invoice sales across average tickets of $15 to $2,500. One example from it is a business with $50,000 a month in invoices at a $150 average ticket, which keeps about $6,100 a year. You can read it as NPS’s 2026 pricing study. That range is for online and invoice sales and does not speak to payments taken any other way.

Four details can affect any comparison. Interchange varies by card type, so ask how a quote treats the cards you accept. Large-bank debit is capped at 0.05% + 21 cents plus 1 cent, and the cap does not apply to small-bank debit. Business and commercial cards can cost more. Level 2 and Level 3 data can lower interchange, so ask whether your system supports it.

Flat rate can still win in some cases. In the study, it can win for very small tickets, around $15 and under in person, and for brand-new, very low-volume businesses. If either describes one of your groups, price that group on its own before you decide, using your own numbers.

Bottom line

The cheapest card processing for a brewery, winery or taproom with a tasting room and a club is the setup with the lowest total across your payment types on your own numbers. Ask every processor the same written questions about the saved-card charge. Sort one month of your statement so each payment is counted once, then add the extra rows for declines, retries, card updates and disputes as the answers arrive. Then compare the monthly totals.

You can also run your own numbers through our savings calculator.

Who wrote this, and where NPS fits

Nationwide Payment Systems (NPS) publishes this guide. We are a payments company based in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, in business since 2001, and we sell merchant accounts and invoicing software, so we are not neutral. We offer interchange pass-through pricing, ACH, a payment gateway and Smart Invoicing, and we also offer flat-rate options. We do not publish a price list. The study we cite was written by our CEO. NPS offers a free statement review. Browse more in our payments guides.

Frequently asked questions

What is the cheapest card processing for a brewery, winery or taproom with a tasting room and a club?

The cheapest setup is the one with the lowest total across your payment types on your own numbers. Sort a recent statement into groups so each payment is counted once, price each group on the processor’s published lines, and compare written quotes line by line.

What should I ask about charging a card a club member has saved?

Ask which fee line covers it, whether a declined attempt costs anything, what each retry costs, what updating an expired card costs, and whether any monthly, gateway or stored-card fee applies. Ask for each answer in writing and for a statement that shows the club charges on their own line.

How do I sort a month’s statement so each payment is counted once?

Write down the statement’s total payment count, dollars and fees. Put every line in exactly one group: tap, dip or swipe, online sales or invoices, saved-card charges, or unsorted, with refunds in their own row. Then add the groups and check that they equal the totals.

What does a small made-up month cost on Square’s lines?

In our made-up math, using Square’s fees page as read on November 13, 2026, 150 tap, dip or swipe payments of $30, 40 online payments of $70, 25 online API payments of $80 and 90 manual entry or card on file charges of $60 cost $511.90 in fees on $14,700.00, or 3.48%. Every count and amount is invented to show the method.

What does a payment dispute cost on Stripe?

Stripe’s pricing page, as read on November 13, 2026, lists three dispute lines at $15.00 each: one when a dispute is received, one when you respond manually (refunded for won disputes) and one for an appeal (not refunded). A dispute that is received and answered manually is $30 before any refund, and three are $90.

What should I count each month for a club?

Count the payments and dollars in each group, saved-card charges attempted and declined, retries, card updates, refunds, disputes received and answered, and every fixed fee on the statement. Then divide total fees by total dollars processed in the same month, for each group and for the whole month.

Does NPS offer a statement review?

Yes. NPS offers a free statement review.