The cheapest card processing for a bakery or coffee roaster that sells in person and online is the setup with the lowest total on your own numbers. To find it, sort one month of payments by how each one was taken, price every group, and add up the totals. If you also charge cards on file for a subscription or a standing order, that is another group to price. This guide starts with the questions that come from selling in more than one place, then shows the method with made-up numbers on the four lines Square lists on its own fees page, covers Stripe’s dispute fees, and ends with what to ask any processor before you sign.
The questions that come with selling in more than one place
If you sell at a shop or market table, through a website, and maybe by charging a card on file each month, you have a longer list to work through. Answer these before you compare a single quote, and write the answers down so you can hand the same numbers to every processor you ask. Put each payment in one group only, so that no payment is counted twice.
- Which payments are tapped, dipped or swiped, and about how many dollars and how many payments is that in a month?
- Which payments come through your website checkout or an invoice, including any invoice to a wholesale or event customer, and how many dollars and payments is that? Ask each processor which line those payments are priced on.
- Does your website connect to the processor through an API? If so, count those payments here and take them out of the group above. How many dollars and payments is that?
- Do you or your staff ever use manual entry, for a phone order or a custom order? Do you charge a card on file for a subscription, a standing order or a repeat purchase? If so, how many dollars and payments is that?
Those answers give you a count and a dollar total for each group, and the four groups should add up to your month’s total payments and total dollars. Write down both numbers for each group, because Square’s four lines each list a percentage plus a fixed number of cents.
Now the questions for the processor. Ask for the answers in writing, one group at a time:
- What is the price for tap, dip or swipe, for online or invoices, for online API and for manual entry or card on file?
- Does one account cover all of them, or does the website need a separate account, a gateway or a separate agreement?
- If the tap, dip or swipe price and the online price are different, which price applies when a customer orders on your website and pays when they pick up?
- Do all of your payments show up on one statement, with each group on its own line?
- What are the monthly, gateway, statement, equipment, PCI, minimum and early termination fees?
Before you sign
Ask every processor these questions in writing
- Ask what the price is for tap, dip or swipe, for online or invoices, for online API, and for manual entry or card on file
- Ask whether one account covers all payment types, or whether the website needs a separate account, gateway or agreement
- Ask which price applies when a customer orders online and pays at pickup
- Ask what the monthly, gateway, statement, equipment, PCI, minimum and early termination fees are
- Ask what a dispute costs, what is refunded if you win, and what the processor needs from you to respond
- Ask for the markup in writing if a processor quotes interchange pass-through, and confirm it is fixed
Square’s fees page (squareup.com/help/us/en/article/5068-square-fees-overview), as read on November 13, 2026, lists these four lines: 2.6% + 15 cents for tap, dip or swipe, 3.3% + 30 cents for online or invoices, 2.9% + 30 cents for online API, and 3.5% + 15 cents for manual entry or card on file. Open that page for today’s figures before you rely on any figure here. When you sort your month, use those four names for your groups, then ask Square in writing which line each of your payment types is priced on. Other names to look at include PayPal, Clover, Toast, Helcim and QuickBooks Payments. We state no figure for them, so read each one’s own pricing page and use the same method.
Square’s four lines
What each payment type costs at Square
- Tap, dip or swipe2.6% + 15¢Tap, dip or swipeAs read on November 13, 2026; check the page for today’s figures
- Online or invoices3.3% + 30¢Online or invoicesAsk Square which line your invoice payments land on
- Online API2.9% + 30¢Online APIOnly if your website connects through an API
- Manual entry or card on file3.5% + 15¢Manual entry or card on fileAsk Square in writing whether this covers later charges to a card on file
See NPS’s page: “Mobile Payment Processing for Small Businesses“.
The same $60 on each of Square’s four lines, and a made-up month
This is made-up math to show the method, not a promise about your account and not a price list for any bakery or roaster. We priced a $60 payment on each of the four lines Square lists, as read on November 13, 2026. The $60 is invented for the example. These are four line prices for one amount, not four alternatives for the same payment.
- Tap, dip or swipe, 2.6% + 15 cents: $1.56 + $0.15 = $1.71, which is 2.85% of $60.
- Online or invoices, 3.3% + 30 cents: $1.98 + $0.30 = $2.28, which is 3.80% of $60.
- Online API, 2.9% + 30 cents: $1.74 + $0.30 = $2.04, which is 3.40% of $60.
- Manual entry or card on file, 3.5% + 15 cents: $2.10 + $0.15 = $2.25, which is 3.75% of $60.
Made-up math, $60 payment
A $60 payment on each of Square’s four lines
| Payment type | Rate | Fee on $60 |
|---|---|---|
| Tap, dip or swipe | 2.6% + 15¢ | $1.71 (2.85%) |
| Online or invoices | 3.3% + 30¢ | $2.28 (3.80%) |
| Online API | 2.9% + 30¢ | $2.04 (3.40%) |
| Manual entry or card on file | 3.5% + 15¢ | $2.25 (3.75%) |
Each of Square’s four lines adds a fixed number of cents to every payment, so the count of payments in each group is the number to find first.
Now a month, again made up. Say a business has 300 payments of $60 each by tap, dip or swipe, 90 payments of $80 each through online or invoices, and 40 payments of $50 each by manual entry or card on file, with nothing through online API. For this example we put each group on the Square line with the same name. Which line your own payments land on is a question for Square, and this example does not settle it. Here are the fees:
- Tap, dip or swipe: a $60 payment costs $1.71, so 300 payments cost $513.00 on $18,000.
- Online or invoices: an $80 payment costs $2.64 + $0.30 = $2.94, so 90 payments cost $264.60 on $7,200.
- Manual entry or card on file: a $50 payment costs $1.75 + $0.15 = $1.90, so 40 payments cost $76.00 on $2,000.
The month adds up to $513.00 + $264.60 + $76.00 = $853.60 in fees on $27,200 processed. Divide the fees by the dollars and you get 3.14%. Over twelve identical months, the made-up fees come to $10,243.20. Use your own counts and dollars from the questions above in the same steps and you have your own number.
See NPS’s page: “Cheapest Card Processing for Very Small Tickets (Coffee Shops and Food Trucks)“.
If you charge a card on file for a subscription: what to ask
If you sell a coffee subscription, a bread share or a monthly box, and you keep the customer’s card so you can charge it again, put these questions to every processor in writing:
- What does a later charge to a card on file cost, and is it the same line as the first payment?
- Where is the card information stored, and who is responsible for protecting it?
- What does a charge that does not go through cost you, and is there a fee for trying again?
- If you refund a subscription charge, are the processing fees returned to you?
- If a customer disputes a charge, what does the processor charge, what is refunded if you win, and what does it need from you to respond?
- Does the subscription tool connect to the website you already use, or is it a second system with its own fee?
- If a first payment is taken through online or invoices and the card is then kept on file, is the later charge priced on a different line from the first one?
If you use Square, look at its line for manual entry or card on file, at 3.5% + 15 cents as read on November 13, 2026. Ask Square in writing whether that line covers your later charges to a card on file. Do not assume the answer, and ask every other processor the same thing.
Disputes belong on the list too. Stripe’s pricing page, as read on November 13, 2026, lists $15.00 for each dispute received, $15.00 for each dispute you respond to manually (refunded for won disputes) and $15.00 for each dispute appealed (not refunded). In our arithmetic, one dispute that is received and responded to manually costs $15 + $15 = $30 before any refund for a won dispute. Against a $60 payment, $30 is 50% of the payment. Three such disputes cost $90 before any refund. This section prices Stripe’s dispute lines only, and we do not compare the two processors. Ask each processor you are considering what it charges per dispute, then use your own numbers.
See NPS’s page: “The Merchant’s Guide to What You Really Pay for Card Processing“.
Sort a statement by group and find your own number
This method has five steps, and you can use it on any quote you are given:
- Pull your most recent processing statement. If you have more than one account, such as one for the shop and one for the website, pull both.
- Sort the month into groups, using Square’s names: tap, dip or swipe, online or invoices, online API, and manual entry or card on file. Count each payment in one group only.
- For each group, write down the dollar total and the number of payments.
- Add the fees on every line of the statement, including any monthly or statement fees.
- Divide the total fees you paid in a month by the total dollars processed in the same month. Do it again for a second month, to see whether your mix moved.
Then price a quote the same way. Take the quote’s price for each group, set it against your counts and dollars from step three, and add up the total. If a quote gives you one number and no groups, ask for the groups in writing.
Find your own number
Five steps to price any processing quote
-
Pull your statementPull your most recent processing statement.
-
Sort into groupsSort the month into groups, using Square’s names: tap, dip or swipe, online or invoices, online API, and manual entry or card on file.
-
Write down totalsFor each group, write down the dollar total and the number of payments.
-
Add all feesAdd the fees on every line of the statement, including any monthly or statement fees.
-
Divide fees by dollarsDivide the total fees you paid in a month by the total dollars processed in the same month.
Here is a like-for-like comparison with an invented quote, using the online or invoices group from the made-up month above. Suppose another processor quotes an invented 2.5% + 20 cents for online payments. This quote is made up for the example and is not any real company’s price. An $80 online payment costs $2.00 + $0.20 = $2.20 on the invented quote. In the made-up month we put the same $80 payments on Square’s online or invoices line, where each costs $2.94. The gap is 74 cents per payment. Over 90 payments, the gap is $66.60 for the month and $799.20 for twelve months. That is online payments against online payments, both at $80, so the two figures compare like with like. It covers the online or invoices group only. The tap, dip or swipe group and the manual entry or card on file group need their own quotes, priced the same way.
If you sell at a market table or a pop-up on some days and from a shop on others, ask the processor whether tapped, dipped or swiped payments are priced the same in both places, and whether the same equipment works in both.
See NPS’s page: “The Hidden Credit Card Processing Fees Draining Your Business (How to Stop Them Today)“.
Pass-through pricing: what to ask, and what the study says
If a processor quotes interchange pass-through, ask: what is the markup, is it written in the agreement, and is it fixed? NPS sells pass-through, so we are not neutral on this question. Treat this section as one model to check against your own statement, not as proof of savings.
The study we cite, “The Flat-Rate Tax” (2026 Edition), was written by Allen Kopelman, the CEO of NPS. It is a cost model built from published rate schedules, not a survey. In the model, interchange pass-through costs 19% to 31% less than flat rate for online and invoice sales across average tickets of $15 to $2,500. One example from it is a business with $50,000 a month in invoices at a $150 average ticket, which keeps about $6,100 a year. You can read it as NPS’s 2026 pricing study. The 19% to 31% figure is for online and invoice sales only. Your result depends on your own mix and on the quote you are given.
For tap, dip or swipe, ask for a written quote and a sample statement, and price your payments on their own line. Flat rate can still win in some cases. In the study, it can win for very small tickets, around $15 and under in person, and for brand-new, very low-volume businesses. If either describes one of your groups, price that group on your own numbers before you decide.
Four things to ask about when you compare quotes:
- Card type: interchange varies by card type, so ask how a quote treats the cards you accept.
- Debit cards: large-bank debit is capped at 0.05% + 21 cents plus 1 cent, and the cap does not apply to small-bank debit.
- Business and commercial cards: they can cost more.
- Level 2 and Level 3 data: Level 2 and Level 3 data can lower interchange, so ask whether your system supports it.
When you compare a pass-through quote with a flat-rate price, ask for the markup in writing, ask which add-on fees come with it, and run both through the five steps above on your own statement. Do it separately for tap, dip or swipe, for online or invoices, and for manual entry or card on file. Compare group by group first, then compare the monthly totals, and do that before you sign.
See NPS’s page: “Tired of Flat-Rate Processing Fees? Better Payment Options for Growing Businesses“.
Bottom line
The cheapest card processing for a bakery or coffee roaster selling in person and online is the setup with the lowest total on your own numbers. Sort a recent statement into tap, dip or swipe, online or invoices, online API, and manual entry or card on file. Price each group using the processor’s own published lines, including the fixed cents and the dispute fees. Ask every processor the same written questions. Then compare the totals for the whole month, not for one group.
You can also run your own numbers through our savings calculator.
Who wrote this, and where NPS fits
Nationwide Payment Systems (NPS) publishes this guide. We are based in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, in business since 2001, and we sell merchant accounts and invoicing software, so we are not neutral. We offer interchange pass-through pricing, ACH, a payment gateway and Smart Invoicing, and we also offer flat-rate options. We do not publish a price list. The study we cite was written by our CEO. NPS offers a free statement review.
Frequently asked questions
What is the cheapest card processing for a bakery or coffee roaster selling in person and online?
The cheapest setup is the one with the lowest total on your own sorted statement. Sort a month of payments into groups, price each group on a written quote, and divide the total fees you paid in a month by the total dollars processed in the same month. Compare quotes group by group and then by the monthly total.
What four lines does Square list for taking a payment?
Square’s fees page, as read on November 13, 2026, lists 2.6% + 15 cents for tap, dip or swipe, 3.3% + 30 cents for online or invoices, 2.9% + 30 cents for online API, and 3.5% + 15 cents for manual entry or card on file. Check the page for today’s figures, and ask Square which line each of your payment types is priced on.
What does a $60 payment cost on each of Square’s four lines?
Our arithmetic, using Square’s lines as read on November 13, 2026, puts a $60 payment at $1.71 for tap, dip or swipe, $2.28 for online or invoices, $2.04 for online API and $2.25 for manual entry or card on file. That is made-up math to show the method, not a promise about your account.
What should I ask about charging a card on file for a subscription?
Ask what a later charge to a card on file costs and whether it is the same line as the first payment. Ask what a charge that does not go through costs, whether refunds return the processing fee, and what a dispute costs. Ask for every answer in writing.
Is interchange pass-through cheaper than flat rate for online and invoice payments?
In our study’s model, interchange pass-through costs 19% to 31% less for online and invoice sales across average tickets of $15 to $2,500. It is a model from a company that sells pass-through pricing, so test it against your own statement. The model covers online and invoice sales and is not a study of bakeries or roasters. Flat rate can win for very small tickets and for brand-new, very low-volume businesses.
What does a payment dispute cost on Stripe?
Stripe’s pricing page, as read on November 13, 2026, lists $15.00 for each dispute received, $15.00 for each dispute you respond to manually (refunded for won disputes) and $15.00 for each dispute appealed (not refunded). One dispute that is received and answered manually is $30 before any refund, and three are $90 before any refund. Ask any processor you are considering for its dispute fees in writing.
Does NPS offer a statement review?
Yes. NPS offers a free statement review.





