Your real processing rate is not the number on the price sheet. It is your total fees divided by the dollars you collected, and it changes with your average ticket. Our arithmetic: at 2.9% plus 30 cents, a $15 sale costs 4.9% all in, while a $500 sale costs 2.96%. This guide shows the same math at six ticket sizes, how to find your own average ticket, and what to compare once you know it.

The short answer

  • A fixed fee weighs more on a small sale. As read on Stripe’s pricing page on November 13, 2026, the card price is 2.9% plus 30 cents per successful domestic card transaction. Our arithmetic: that works out to 4.9% on a $15 sale and 2.91% on a $2,500 sale.
  • Your average ticket decides which line matters most. On small tickets the fixed cents are the story. On large tickets the percentage is the story.
  • Where you take the payment changes the price. As read on Square’s fees page on November 13, 2026, Square lists 2.6% plus 15 cents for tap, dip or swipe, and 3.3% plus 30 cents for online sales or invoices.
  • Our study is a model. NPS’s 2026 pricing study was written by NPS’s CEO. NPS sells interchange pass-through pricing, so we are not neutral. Treat it as a reason to get a quote, not proof of your savings.
  • Check each processor’s own page. Prices change, and your account may have its own terms.

Stripe vs Square

In-person rates at the same ticket sizes

Price sheet rate
Stripe (card)2.9% plus 30 cents
Square (tap, dip or swipe)2.6% plus 15 cents
Real rate at $15 sale
Stripe (card)4.9%
Square (tap, dip or swipe)3.6%
Real rate at $150 sale
Stripe (card)3.1%
Square (tap, dip or swipe)2.7%
Real rate at $2,500 sale
Stripe (card)2.91%
Square (tap, dip or swipe)2.61%

The headline stays 2.9%, but the real rate falls from 4.9% to 2.91% as the ticket grows. Nothing about the price changed. Only the size of the sale did.

Rates as read on each processor’s fees page on November 13, 2026; our arithmetic, not a promise about your account.

Square Channel Costs

Square’s online rate costs more than in-person

Channel Price sheet rate Real rate at $15 sale
Tap, dip or swipe 2.6% plus 15 cents 3.6%
Online sales or invoices 3.3% plus 30 cents 5.3%
The same business can have a lower real rate in person than online even at the same ticket, because the price sheet is different for each channel.

What “real rate” means, in plain words

Many price sheets, including the Stripe and Square prices above, give two numbers: a percentage and a fixed fee per payment. For example, a flat-rate price of 2.9% plus 30 cents means you pay 2.9 cents of every dollar, plus 30 cents on each payment. Your real rate, also called your effective rate, folds both pieces into one percentage: total fees divided by total dollars collected.

That matters because the two pieces behave differently. The percentage part is the same on every sale. The fixed part is the same dollar amount on every sale, so as a share of the sale it gets smaller as the ticket gets bigger. A business with a $12 average ticket and a business with a $1,200 average ticket can be on the same price sheet and have very different real rates.

This is also why a rate quoted as a percentage alone can mislead. If someone tells you “2.6%” or “2.9%”, ask what the fixed fee is, and then do the division for your own ticket size. Our guide on how to read your merchant statement shows where each part appears.

Six ticket sizes, one flat-rate price (our arithmetic)

This is made-up math to show the method, not a promise about your account. We took Stripe’s 2.9% plus 30 cents, as read on Stripe’s pricing page on November 13, 2026, and worked out the all-in rate for one payment at six sizes.

  • $15 sale: the fee is about 73.5 cents, which is 4.9% of the sale. The fixed 30 cents alone is 2%.
  • $40 sale: the fee is $1.46, which is 3.65%.
  • $150 sale: the fee is $4.65, which is 3.1%.
  • $500 sale: the fee is $14.80, which is 2.96%.
  • $1,000 sale: the fee is $29.30, which is 2.93%.
  • $2,500 sale: the fee is $72.80, which is 2.91%.

Real Rate by Ticket

Small tickets cost far more than 2.9%

  • $15 sale4.9%All-in real rateFixed 30 cents alone is 2% of the sale
  • $500 sale2.96%All-in real rateFee is $14.80
  • $2,500 sale2.91%All-in real rateFee is $72.80

Read down the list and the pattern is clear. The headline stays 2.9%, but the real rate falls from 4.9% to 2.91% as the ticket grows. Nothing about the price changed. Only the size of the sale did.

The same exercise at Square’s in-person price

As read on Square’s fees page on November 13, 2026, Square lists 2.6% plus 15 cents for tap, dip or swipe. Our arithmetic gives the same pattern with a smaller fixed fee.

  • $15 sale: 54 cents, which is 3.6%.
  • $40 sale: $1.19, which is 2.97%.
  • $150 sale: $4.05, which is 2.7%.
  • $2,500 sale: $65.15, which is 2.61%.

For online sales or invoices, Square’s fees page lists 3.3% plus 30 cents. At a $15 sale that is about 80 cents, or 5.3%, and at a $150 sale it is $5.25, or 3.5% (our arithmetic). The same business can have a lower real rate in person than online even at the same ticket, because the price sheet is different for each channel. NPS covers that gap in why Square’s invoice price costs more than in-person.

Why the fixed fee is only half the story

Interchange varies by card type. The large-bank debit cap has a percentage part and a fixed part: large-bank debit is capped at 0.05% plus 21 cents, plus a 1 cent fraud adjustment. Our arithmetic: that cap on a $15 sale is about 23 cents, or about 1.5%, and on a $150 sale it is about 30 cents, or about 0.2%. The cap does not apply to small-bank debit, so do not assume every debit card gets it. NPS has a separate post on whether the debit cap applies to small-bank cards.

Business and commercial cards can cost more in interchange, and Level 2 and Level 3 data can lower those costs. So a larger ticket does not guarantee a lower rate. It depends on which cards your customers use and how the payment is submitted. The point of the comparison is to see each piece instead of one blended number. For a deeper look at where the money goes, read where Stripe fees actually go.

What the study found by ticket size

The study is called “The Flat-Rate Tax,” and it was written by Allen Kopelman, the CEO of NPS. It is a cost model built from published rate schedules, not a survey.

  • Online and invoice sales: in the model, interchange pass-through costs 19% to 31% less than flat rate across average tickets from $15 to $2,500.
  • One example: $50,000 a month in invoices at a $150 average ticket keeps about $6,100 a year in the model. That is the study’s figure, not a promise.
  • Where flat rate can still win: for very small in-person tickets, around $15 and under, and for brand-new businesses with very low volume.

Read that last bullet as a lesson about ticket size. That is the study’s finding, so check it on your own tickets. NPS goes through those cases in when flat rate wins. Because the study comes from a company that sells pass-through pricing, test it against your own statement.

How to find your real rate and your average ticket

You need two or three months of statements or dashboard exports. The steps are the same for any processor.

  1. Get total card volume for the month. This is the dollars collected by card, before fees.
  2. Get the number of card payments. Look for a transaction count on your dashboard or statement summary.
  3. Divide volume by count. That is your average ticket. Do it separately for in-person, online and invoice sales if you take all three, because each can have its own price.
  4. Add up every fee line. Include the percentage fees, the per-transaction fees, and any monthly, gateway, statement or dispute fees.
  5. Divide total fees by total volume. Multiply by 100. That is your real rate.
  6. Compare it to the price sheet. If your real rate is well above what the price sheet implies at your ticket size, look for extra fee lines.

Find Your Real Rate

Six steps to your true processing cost

  1. Get total card volumeThis is the dollars collected by card, before fees.
  2. Get the number of card paymentsLook for a transaction count on your dashboard or statement summary.
  3. Divide volume by countThat is your average ticket.
  4. Add up every fee lineInclude the percentage fees, the per-transaction fees, and any monthly, gateway, statement or dispute fees.
  5. Divide total fees by total volumeMultiply by 100.
  6. Compare it to the price sheetIf your real rate is well above what the price sheet implies at your ticket size, look for extra fee lines.
Use two or three months of statements or dashboard exports for the most reliable result.

Our guide on how much you are really paying on Stripe, Square, PayPal or QuickBooks runs the same exercise across several providers.

What the fixed fee adds up to over a month (our arithmetic)

Here is made-up math to show the method, not a promise. Suppose a business collects $10,000 a month by card under a 2.9% plus 30 cents price.

  • At a $15 average ticket: about 667 payments, so the fixed part is about $200 a month. Total fees are about $490.
  • At a $50 average ticket: 200 payments, so the fixed part is $60. Total fees are $350.
  • At a $150 average ticket: about 67 payments, so the fixed part is about $20. Total fees are about $310.
  • At a $500 average ticket: 20 payments, so the fixed part is $6. Total fees are $296.

Same $10,000, same price sheet, and a gap of nearly $200 a month between the smallest and largest ticket. The practical lesson is that the fixed fee is the part to inspect first if your tickets are small, and the percentage is the part to inspect first if your tickets are large.

What to do with the answer

Once you know your average ticket and your real rate, the next step depends on where you land.

  • Small tickets, in person. Compare the fixed per-payment fee line by line. Ask any processor you are considering what its per-transaction fee is, in writing. NPS has a post for restaurants and one for retail stores where tickets run small to mid-size.
  • Mid-size and large tickets, online or by invoice. The percentage and any invoice or keyed-card add-ons carry the weight. See cheapest card processing for invoices and payment links.
  • A mix of both. Calculate each channel separately. A blended number hides which channel costs the most.

For the wider view of the cost question, see cheapest payment processing in 2026, or browse the payments guides.

When your current price is probably fine

Do not switch just because a percentage looks high on paper. Staying put can be the better choice when:

  • Your volume is very low, and a simple flat price is enough for you.
  • Your tickets are very small and in person, around $15 and under, where the study’s model says flat rate can still win.
  • You rely on other tools from your current provider, and keeping one system matters more to you than the price difference.

It starts to deserve a look when your yearly fees are a number you notice, when your tickets are larger, or when many of your customers pay online or by invoice.

Questions to ask any processor

  • What is the markup over interchange, in writing, and is it fixed?
  • What is the fixed fee per transaction, and does it differ for keyed, online or invoice payments?
  • Are there monthly, gateway, statement or PCI fees?
  • What are the dispute fees, and are they refunded if I win?
  • Can I see a sample statement that shows each fee on its own line?

If an answer is “it depends,” ask on what. A clear answer lets you do the division above yourself.

Questions to Ask

Ask every processor these five questions

  • Ask what the markup over interchange is, in writing, and whether it is fixed
  • Ask what the fixed fee per transaction is, and whether it differs for keyed, online or invoice payments
  • Ask whether there are monthly, gateway, statement or PCI fees
  • Ask what the dispute fees are, and whether they are refunded if you win
  • Ask to see a sample statement that shows each fee on its own line

You can also run your own average ticket and monthly volume through our savings calculator.

A ten-minute check before you change anything

Open your last full month of card sales on your processor’s dashboard or statement. Write down three numbers: total card sales, the number of card payments, and the total fees you paid on those payments.

Divide total card sales by the number of payments. That is your average ticket. Divide total fees by total card sales. That is your real rate, and it is the number to compare against any quote.

Now look at the percentage on your price sheet. If your real rate is higher than that percentage, the difference is the fixed cents and any other lines on your statement. Ask your processor to name each line.

Write the gap down in dollars per month. A gap you can name in dollars is easier to weigh than a gap in percentage points.

When you compare any new quote, run it through the same two numbers, your average ticket and your monthly card sales. A quote that looks lower on its percentage can still cost more at your ticket size.

Who wrote this, and where NPS fits

Nationwide Payment Systems (NPS) publishes this guide. We are a payments company based in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, in business since 2001, and we sell merchant accounts and invoicing software, so we are not neutral. We offer interchange-plus pricing, ACH, a payment gateway and Smart Invoicing, and we also offer flat-rate options. We do not publish a price list. The study we cite was written by our CEO. NPS offers a free statement review. Browse more in our payments guides.

We are not the right fit for every business. If your tickets are very small, your volume is very low, or a simpler setup already works for you, it may cost you less than a switch.

Bottom line

The percentage on a price sheet tells you only part of the cost. The fixed fee per payment makes your real rate climb as your average ticket shrinks: our arithmetic puts 2.9% plus 30 cents at 4.9% on a $15 sale and 2.96% on a $500 sale. Find your average ticket, divide your total fees by your total volume, and compare that number to a written quote, line by line. If you would like a second opinion, you can contact our team.

Frequently asked questions

What is an effective processing rate?

It is your total processing fees divided by the total dollars you collected, shown as a percentage. It includes the fixed per-transaction part, so it is higher than the percentage on the price sheet whenever there is a fixed fee, and it moves with your average ticket.

Why does a small average ticket cost more per dollar?

The Stripe and Square prices above each include a fixed fee on every payment, 30 cents in Stripe’s card price. Our arithmetic: that 30 cents is 2% of a $15 sale but 0.2% of a $150 sale. The percentage part stays the same, so the fixed part is what changes your real rate.

What is my average ticket?

Divide the total dollars you collected by cards in a month by the number of card payments in that month. Use two or three months, and calculate it separately for in-person, online and invoice sales if you take all three.

At what ticket size does flat rate stop making sense?

There is no single line. In the study’s model, flat rate can still win for very small in-person tickets, around $15 and under, and for brand-new, very low-volume businesses. For online and invoice sales, the model finds interchange pass-through costs 19% to 31% less across average tickets from $15 to $2,500.

Does a bigger ticket always mean a lower rate?

Not always. The fixed fee shrinks as a share of the sale, but a business or commercial card can carry a higher interchange cost, and Stripe and Square list higher prices for invoices and keyed cards. Read your own statement to see what you paid.

How do I find my real rate on my statement?

Add up every fee line for the month, divide by total card volume, and multiply by 100. Then divide total card volume by the number of transactions to get your average ticket. Our guide to reading a merchant statement walks through the lines.

Does NPS review my statement for free?

Yes. NPS offers a free statement review.