To compare merchant account costs and rates, add up every line a quote charges, not only the rate. Sort the lines by when they are charged: once, on every payment, every month, every year, when an event such as a dispute happens, and on the way out. Price each group on your own month and your own year, then divide the year’s total by the year’s dollars processed. That one total is the number this worksheet compares, and it is how this page looks for the cheapest merchant account for its made-up volume. If a quote is interchange pass-through, the same worksheet applies, with the interchange amount and the processor’s own line on separate rows. Every worked figure on this page is made up to show the method. None of it is a promise or a price from any real processor. The only exceptions are the study figures in the last FAQ answer, which are labeled as the study’s.
Step 1: Build the frame, one month, one year and one volume for every quote
Fix the sales first and keep them fixed for every quote. Here is an invented business to show the method. In one made-up month it runs $18,400 through cards in 230 payments, so the average payment is $80 (our arithmetic: $18,400 divided by 230). In the made-up month, interchange and card-brand costs come to $322.00, which is 1.75% of $18,400. To keep the page readable, the invented year is twelve identical months: $220,800 in 2,760 payments. A real year will move around.
Now the worksheet. Make one row for every line on every quote, with six cells: the line’s name as the quote writes it, when it is charged, the amount in the quote, the amount on your first real statement, the dollars for your month and the dollars for your year. If a line does not apply, write the word “none” in the amount cell, and ask for that word in writing. Treat a blank cell as a question you have not asked yet, and a “none” as an answer you have in writing.
This page prices two invented quotes on the invented month. Neither is a price from a real processor. They are built to be compared line for line.
- Quote P (invented, interchange pass-through): the interchange and card-brand costs from your own statement, invented here at $322.00 a month, plus an invented processor line of 0.60% + 5 cents per payment, a $25 monthly fee, a $10 monthly gateway fee, a $75 one-time setup fee, a $99 annual fee, $25 per dispute, and a $295 fee if you leave in the first year.
- Quote F (invented, flat): 2.65% + 20 cents per payment and $20 per dispute. Setup, monthly, annual and exit lines are all “none”.
The made-up month has two disputes. That is an invented count for the example, and you would use your own. The rest of the page prices these two quotes group by group.
See NPS’s page: “How to Read Your Merchant Statement and understand how much you are paying!“.
See NPS’s page: “How a Slow Month Changes the Cost of a Monthly-Fee Processor“.
Step 2: Lines charged once, and lines charged on every payment
Start with the lines charged once. For each, ask whether it appears on a monthly statement, and where. These are the questions for lines charged once. Put each one to the processor and write the answer in the cell for that line.
- Is there an application fee, a setup fee or a gateway setup fee, and is each one charged one time only?
- Do I buy or lease the terminal or card reader, and what is the full price over the whole term, in writing?
- Is there a fee to connect the account to my website, my invoicing tool or my point-of-sale system, and is any of the work mine to pay for?
- If the application is not approved, is any of these refunded?
- Is any one-time line waived only if I stay for a set period, and what is the period?
In the invented quotes, Quote P has one line in this group, a $75 setup fee, and Quote F has “none”. Hold the $75 aside for the year view in Step 3, because in this worksheet a one-time line counts in the first year only.
Next come the lines charged on every payment. Price them on the whole month, and keep the interchange amount in the same row as the processor’s line, so the two quotes are priced on the same base. On Quote P, the processor’s 0.60% of $18,400 is $110.40, and its 5 cents on 230 payments is $11.50. Add the $322.00 of interchange and card-brand costs and the per-payment group comes to $443.90. On Quote F, 2.65% of $18,400 is $487.60, and 20 cents on 230 payments is $46.00, so the group comes to $533.60. The two groups differ by $89.70 in the month, our arithmetic.
In these invented quotes, Quote P’s 0.60% is added to the interchange and card-brand costs, and Quote F’s 2.65% is the whole per-payment percentage. So the two percentages are not the same kind of number here. Compare the dollars of the whole group, not the two percentages. These are the questions for the per-payment group:
- What is the percentage line, and what dollar amount does it apply to? Does that amount include sales tax or tips?
- What is the cents line, and is it charged on refunds, voids or declined attempts?
- Are there any other per-payment lines, such as an authorization fee or a batch fee?
- If the quote is interchange pass-through, where on my statement does the interchange amount appear, and where does the processor’s own markup appear, as two separate lines?
- Is the processor’s line the same for every way I take payments, such as in person, online, by invoice or typed in by hand?
- Business and commercial cards can cost more. Where does the quote say how those cards are priced?
- If I sell to other businesses, does the quote say anything about Level 2 and Level 3 data? Level 2 and Level 3 data can lower interchange.
See NPS’s page: “What Does Card Processing Cost at $10,000 a Month vs $100,000 a Month?“.
Step 3: Monthly, yearly and per-event lines, then the first-year total
Now the lines that, in the invented quotes, do not change with sales. Ask for each one by name, with an amount and a schedule.
- Is there a monthly fee? Is there a gateway fee, a statement fee, a compliance fee or a minimum? For each one, what is the amount and what is the schedule?
- Is there a line billed once a year, and what month does it hit?
- What is the fee for each dispute, and is it charged when I win?
- What is the fee for a refund, for a returned payment or for a retrieval request, if the quote has them?
- If the quote covers ACH, is the pricing for ACH on its own lines, and are returns priced separately?
Here is the month for each invented quote, with everything in it. Quote P is $443.90 for the per-payment group, plus the $25 monthly fee and the $10 gateway fee, which is $478.90. Add two disputes at $25 each, which is $50.00, and the month is $528.90, or $2.87 per $100 processed. Quote F is $533.60 for the per-payment group, plus two disputes at $20 each, which is $40.00, so the month is $573.60, or $3.12 per $100. In this made-up month, Quote P is $44.70 lower.
Now the first year, which is where the one-time and yearly lines arrive. Quote P is 12 months of $528.90, which is $6,346.80, plus the $75 setup fee and the $99 annual fee, for $6,520.80. That is $2.95 per $100 on $220,800. Quote F is 12 months of $573.60, which is $6,883.20, or $3.12 per $100. The first-year gap is $362.40 in Quote P’s favor. Twelve times the monthly gap of $44.70 would be $536.40, but the $174 of one-time and yearly lines only show up in the year. They moved Quote P from $2.87 to $2.95 per $100 (our arithmetic), so in this example the month view and the year view do not match.
For your own quotes, put each group’s total in one row, then the year, then the cost per $100, which is the year’s total divided by the year’s dollars processed, times 100.
See NPS’s page: “Why Your Effective Processing Rate Is Higher Than the Rate You Were Quoted, and How to Find the Gap“.
Step 4: Lines on the way out, and the second year
The last group is the exit lines. Our first-year totals above leave them out, so price them next. Ask these before you sign anything, and ask for each answer in writing. This is not legal advice, and we are not stating what any contract contains.
- How long is the term, and what happens at the end of it? Does it renew by itself, and how much notice do I have to give?
- If I leave early, what is charged, and how is the amount worked out?
- If I leave in the first year and in the second year, is the amount the same?
- If I leased equipment, what is owed on it if I leave?
- Can any line change during the term? How much written notice do I get before a change?
- Does any line start, rise or drop after an introductory period? On what date?
- Is there a fee to close the account, or a fee on the final statement?
Test an answer on the invented quotes. Quote P has a $295 line if you leave in the first year. If the business leaves then, the first year on Quote P is $6,520.80 plus $295, which is $6,815.80, or $3.09 per $100. Quote F in the same year is $6,883.20, or $3.12 per $100. In the made-up year, the exit line cuts Quote P’s lead from $362.40 to $67.40, and Quote P is still lower. In this example, one answer in the exit group moves the gap by $295, so ask for it before you compare.
Now the second year, which is a year with no setup fee. Quote P is 12 months of $528.90 plus the $99 annual fee, which is $6,445.80, or $2.92 per $100. Quote F is still $6,883.20. The gap in the second year is $437.40. If you plan to stay, price the second year as its own row. If you are not sure, price both years and the exit.
Last test for this group. Suppose that after signing Quote P, an invented $9.95 monthly line shows up that was not in the quote. Twelve of those are $119.40, so the first year becomes $6,520.80 plus $119.40, which is $6,640.20, or $3.01 per $100. It still beats Quote F’s $3.12 in the first year, by $243.00. Add the exit fee to that, and Quote P is $6,935.20, or $3.14 per $100, which is $52.00 above Quote F. In this example, the order flips only when both the unlisted line and the exit fee are added. Write your first statement’s lines next to the quote’s lines, and put a question mark on every line that appears on one and not the other.
See NPS’s page: “Top 3 Mistakes When Setting Up a New Merchant Account“.
Step 5: Read the totals, then ask for the schedule in writing
Look at your table the way the invented one reads. Quote P had the lowest first-year total as quoted, the lowest total with the exit fee alone, and the lowest total with the extra $9.95 line alone. It had the highest total only when both were added. Quote F never moved off $6,883.20. In this example, a single rate would not have shown any of that, and no single extra row flipped the order, but two rows together did.
Work out the cost per $100 for the first year, the second year and the exit case. If the same quote is lowest in all three on your worksheet, you have your answer. If the order changes, the answer depends on what you plan to do, and you now know which line decides it.
Then ask each processor for the same document: a written schedule of every line, with the amount, the schedule it is charged on and the word “none” on every line that does not apply. Ask whether the schedule you were given is the full schedule, and ask for a sample statement. If a quote gives only a rate, the other rows of your worksheet stay blank.
NPS’s 2026 pricing study is a cost model built from published rate schedules, not a survey, and we sell pass-through pricing. Test every quote on your own year, ours included.
See NPS’s page: “Merchant Account Cost Calculator: What to Plug In and How to Read the Result“.
See NPS’s page: “Cheapest Payment Processing in 2026: What You Really Pay and How to Compare“.
Bottom line
On this worksheet, a rate is one row of the sheet. To compare merchant account costs, fix one month and one year of your own sales, then price every quote on the lines charged once, on every payment, every month, every year, per event and on exit. In the made-up example the first-year totals were $6,520.80 and $6,883.20, a gap of $362.40, and an exit fee together with an unlisted monthly line moved the order to $6,935.20 against $6,883.20. Divide each total by the dollars processed, ask for every line in writing with “none” where it does not apply, and put any line that appears on a statement and not on the quote on your list of questions.
You can also run your own numbers through our savings calculator.
Who wrote this, and where NPS fits
Nationwide Payment Systems (NPS) publishes this guide. We are a payments company based in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, in business since 2001, and we sell merchant accounts and invoicing software, so we are not neutral. We offer interchange pass-through pricing, ACH, a payment gateway and Smart Invoicing, and we also offer flat-rate options. We do not publish a price list. The study we cite was written by our CEO. NPS offers a free statement review. Browse more in our payments guides.
Frequently asked questions
What should I add up when comparing merchant account costs?
Add every line a quote charges, sorted by when it is charged: once, on every payment, every month, every year, per event such as a dispute, and on exit. Price each group on your own month and year, then divide the year’s total by the year’s dollars processed. In our made-up example that gave $6,520.80 for one quote and $6,883.20 for the other on $220,800.
How do I compare merchant account rates when the quotes list different lines?
Put every line from every quote on one sheet, and write “none” where a quote has no such line. Price all the quotes on the same month and the same year, then compare the totals and the cost per $100, not the rates. In the made-up pair, 0.60% + 5 cents is added to the interchange and card-brand costs, and 2.65% + 20 cents is not, so this page compares them as dollars, not as percentages.
Is the cheapest merchant account the one with the lowest rate?
Price the whole sheet before you decide, because in this page’s made-up example the lowest total did not hold in every case. The quote with the lower first-year total, $6,520.80 against $6,883.20, stayed lower at $6,815.80 with a $295 fee for leaving in the first year, and became the higher one, at $6,935.20, once an unlisted $9.95 monthly line was added as well. Price the first year, the second year and the exit case, and see which quote stays lowest.
What should I ask about an interchange pass-through quote?
Ask where the interchange amount appears on the statement and where the processor’s own markup appears, as two separate lines. Ask whether the markup in the quote is the whole markup, and ask for a written schedule of every other line. Then price the quote on your own month, with the interchange amount from your own statement.
What does a fee for leaving early change in a comparison?
It adds a row to the exit case. In the made-up example, a $295 line cut one quote’s first-year lead from $362.40 to $67.40, and with an unlisted $9.95 monthly line as well it put that quote $52.00 above the other. Ask how the amount is worked out, whether it changes between year one and year two, and ask for the answer in writing.
Does NPS offer a statement review?
Yes. NPS offers a free statement review.
Does the study say interchange pass-through will cost me less?
The study reports what its model found, not what you will pay. It is a cost model built from published rate schedules, not a survey, and it comes from a processor that sells pass-through pricing. In the model, interchange pass-through costs 19% to 31% less than flat rate for online and invoice sales across average tickets of $15 to $2,500, and one example is $50,000 a month in invoices at a $150 average ticket, which keeps about $6,100 a year. Those are the study’s figures, not made-up ones, and your result depends on your own statements and your own quotes.





