What to compare in invoicing software that accepts credit cards and ACH is the total each package charges on your own paid invoices, split by how each invoice was paid. We cannot name a price for any package you will be quoted, so this page gives you a ten-question worksheet to put to each one in writing, then prices one made-up month of 50 invoices on two invented packages. In that month, Package Two costs less when every invoice is paid by card, and Package One costs less from the 5th ACH payment when the largest invoices move to ACH first. Those figures are invented to show the method. They are not a promise and not a price from any real package. You repeat the same steps with your own last three months.
Step 1: Write down your invoices and how each one was paid
Price every package on the same month so the totals can be compared. For each of your last three months, write down the number of invoices paid, the dollars they added up to, and how many of those invoices were paid by card and how many by ACH. Then split the invoices into three size groups, because the made-up month below shows a dollar cap and a flat amount changing the result by invoice size.
Also write down two shares. The first is the share of your invoices paid by ACH counted by invoices. The second is the share counted by dollars. In the made-up month below they can sit far apart, and the page shows why that matters.
The rest of this page uses one invented month for an invented business. It is not a real company and not a typical one:
- Small invoices: 40 invoices at $200, which is $8,000
- Medium invoices: 4 invoices at $900, which is $3,600
- Large invoices: 6 invoices at $4,000, which is $24,000
That is 50 invoices and $35,600 for the month. Write your own month in the same three rows before you read on. If your own invoices fall into more than three sizes, use more rows.
See NPS’s page: “Cheapest card processing for a service business using invoices and payment links“.
Step 2: The ten-question comparison worksheet
Put the same ten questions to every package on your list and ask for each answer in writing. An answer given only in a phone call or on a sales page is not yet an answer in writing. Leave a blank when an answer is missing, and do not fill the blank with a guess.
- What is the card price on a paid invoice, in a percentage and a number of cents, and does it change with the type of card?
- What is the ACH price on a paid invoice? Is it a percentage, a flat amount, or a percentage with a cap, and if there is a cap, what is it in dollars?
- Is there a monthly, yearly or per-user line, and does it change with the number of invoices you send?
- Can the customer choose card or ACH on the same invoice, or does the package show only the one you switch on?
- How many days pass between a paid card invoice and the money reaching your bank account, and how many for a paid ACH invoice?
- What happens to the fee when an ACH payment is returned, when a card payment is refunded, and when an invoice is voided after it was paid?
- What does each dispute cost at each stage, and which amounts come back if you win?
- Are saved cards, saved bank accounts, recurring invoices, reminders and an export to your accounting software separate lines? Ask for a price or a no for each one.
- Does the statement show the fee on each paid invoice, or only a monthly total? Ask for a sample statement with the fee lines visible.
- What are the terms for ending the agreement, and is there a minimum fee per month?
Questions 1 to 3 give you the numbers for the arithmetic in Step 3. Question 4 asks whether your customers can pay the way you priced. Question 5 asks about timing, question 6 about returns, refunds and voids, question 7 about disputes and question 8 about extra lines. Questions 9 and 10 ask about statement detail and the terms for leaving. Give each answer a line in your worksheet even if the line is a zero.
If one package on your list is Stripe Invoicing, these are the lines Stripe’s pricing page listed when we read it on November 13, 2026, so you know what to ask about. Invoicing is listed at 0.4% per paid invoice. A separate line lists +0.5% for manually entered cards. The card line is 2.9% + 30 cents per successful domestic card transaction, as its own line. Check the page for today’s price. Ask Stripe in writing which of its lines apply to an invoice paid each way your customers pay, then add the lines from the written answer. We do not compare Stripe with the other packages on this page.
See NPS’s page: “Stripe Invoicing Fee: What the Extra 0.4% Really Costs a Small Business“.
Step 3: Price one made-up month on two invented packages
Here are two invented packages. Nothing about them is real.
- Package One (invented): card at 2.75% + 21 cents per paid invoice, ACH at 0.85% with a cap of $7 per paid invoice, no monthly line
- Package Two (invented): card at 2.40% + 27 cents per paid invoice, ACH at a flat $1.10 per paid invoice, an $85 monthly line
Our arithmetic: each payment’s fee is rounded to the cent (half up), multiplied by the count, then fixed monthly lines are added. Every figure below was computed that way with python3.
First, what one paid invoice costs in each size group:
- $200 invoice: Package One charges $5.71 by card and $1.70 by ACH. Package Two charges $5.07 by card and $1.10 by ACH.
- $900 invoice: Package One charges $24.96 by card and $7.00 by ACH, because 0.85% would be $7.65 and the invented cap holds it at $7. Package Two charges $21.87 by card and $1.10 by ACH.
- $4,000 invoice: Package One charges $110.21 by card and $7.00 by ACH, because 0.85% would be $34.00 and the cap holds it at $7. Package Two charges $96.27 by card and $1.10 by ACH.
Now the whole month with every one of the 50 invoices paid by card. Package One costs 40 x $5.71 = $228.40, plus 4 x $24.96 = $99.84, plus 6 x $110.21 = $661.26, which is $989.50 and no monthly line. Package Two costs 40 x $5.07 = $202.80, plus 4 x $21.87 = $87.48, plus 6 x $96.27 = $577.62, which is $867.90, plus the $85 monthly line, which is $952.90.
In the made-up month with all 50 invoices paid by card, Package One comes to $989.50 and Package Two comes to $952.90, so Package Two costs $36.60 less. Per invoice that is $19.79 and $19.06. The monthly line alone would point to Package One, and the card percentage alone would point to Package Two. Only pricing the month settles it.
The same arithmetic works with any number of invoices of a single size. If every invoice were $900 and paid by card, Package One costs less through 27 invoices a month and Package Two costs less from 28. That count is the first one where Package Two’s total is lower, found by trying every count from 1 upward. There is no tie. Your own break-even moves with your average invoice, so run it on yours.
See NPS’s page: “Merchant Account Costs: What to Add Up Before You Compare Rates“.
Step 4: Move the ACH share and watch the answer change
Now change one thing. Keep the same 50 invoices and the same two invented packages, and move some invoices from card to ACH. Four cases, with the invoices that move named in each:
- Everything by card (0 ACH payments): Package One $989.50, Package Two $952.90. Package Two costs $36.60 less.
- Only the 6 large invoices by ACH (6 ACH payments): Package One $370.24, Package Two $381.88. Package One costs $11.64 less.
- The 4 medium and 6 large invoices by ACH (10 ACH payments): Package One $298.40, Package Two $298.80. Package One costs $0.40 less.
- All 50 invoices by ACH: Package One $138.00, Package Two $140.00. Package One costs $2.00 less.
The answer flipped between the first case and the second. Per invoice, the second case is $7.40 for Package One and $7.64 for Package Two. Per $100 invoiced, it is $1.04 and $1.07. In the fourth case it is $2.76 and $2.80 per invoice.
To find where the flip happens, move invoices to ACH one at a time, largest first. With 4 ACH payments Package One comes to $576.66 and Package Two comes to $572.22, so Package Two still costs less. With 5 ACH payments Package One comes to $473.45 and Package Two comes to $477.05. Package One costs less from the 5th ACH payment and at every count after it, and there is no tie at any count from 0 to 50.
Look at what the flip depends on. In the second case, 6 of the 50 invoices are paid by ACH. That is 12% counted by invoices. Those 6 invoices are $24,000 of the $35,600, which is about 67% counted by dollars. Moving one $4,000 invoice from card to ACH takes $103.21 off Package One’s bill ($110.21 down to $7.00) and $95.17 off Package Two’s ($96.27 down to $1.10). In these invented packages, the card fee that moves away grows with the invoice dollars, while an ACH fee that is capped or flat grows only with the count. That is why the 6 largest invoices change the answer, and it is why Step 1 asks for both shares. It is also a reason to ask how many of your own invoices, and which sizes, your customers would actually pay by ACH, and not only which package has the lower rate.
If you are not sure, price the page’s four cases with your own numbers and see which package wins across all of them. If one package wins in every case, the choice may be simpler than if it wins only in the case you hope for. In the made-up month, neither package wins in all four.
See NPS’s page: “Cheapest Card Processing for a Wholesaler Selling on Net-30 Invoices“.
Step 5: Read the written answers and decide
Put your three months, the ten answers for each package and the four cases on one sheet. For each package, fill in the card price and the ACH price from questions 1 and 2, add the monthly line from question 3, and total the month for each case. Then do three checks before you pick.
- Compare like with like. Price every package on the same month and the same split between card and ACH, so the totals line up.
- Look for blanks. A blank on question 6, 7, 8 or 10 may be a cost you have not counted yet, a blank on question 5 is a gap in your cash timing, and a blank on question 9 is a gap in what you can check. Ask again in writing, and say which question you are asking.
- Build the total from every line, not the headline. Add every line a package gave you into its total for the month. If a package gave you only a headline percentage, ask for the other lines.
On the card side, ask each package to state its card price in writing, either as one percentage plus cents or as separate network and markup lines. NPS’s 2026 pricing study is a cost model built from published rate schedules, not a survey. It says interchange pass-through costs 19% to 31% less than flat rate for online and invoice sales across average tickets of $15 to $2,500, and it says flat rate can still win for very small tickets and for brand-new businesses with very low volume. Check any conclusion from a model against your own months. Business and commercial cards can cost more, and Level 2 and Level 3 data can lower interchange, so ask each package how it treats those cards.
The study gives one example of invoice volume. At $50,000 a month in invoices and a $150 average ticket, the model keeps about $6,100 a year. That is the study’s example. It is not a figure for your business, and none of the made-up numbers on this page come from it.
Smart Invoicing is NPS’s invoicing software, and NPS offers ACH. NPS publishes no price list, so we cannot give you its lines on this page, and we are not neutral. If you ask NPS the same ten questions, put the answers on the same sheet as every other package and total them the same way.
See NPS’s page: “ACH and Credit Card Invoicing Platform“.
See NPS’s page: “In-Person vs Online vs Invoice: Which Sales Channel Costs the Most to Process?“.
See NPS’s page: “Cheapest Payment Processing in 2026: What You Really Pay and How to Compare“.
Bottom line
What to compare in invoicing software that accepts credit cards and ACH is the monthly total on your own invoices, priced for each way an invoice is paid. In the made-up month, Package One cost $989.50 and Package Two cost $952.90 with all 50 invoices paid by card, and Package One cost $138.00 against $140.00 with all 50 paid by ACH. Package Two was cheaper through 4 ACH payments and Package One from the 5th, when the largest invoices moved first. To see your own result, write down three months of invoices by size and by payment method, put the ten questions to each package in writing, price four cases with your own numbers, and pick the package that holds up across the cases you think are likely.
You can also run your own invoice numbers through our savings calculator.
Who wrote this, and where NPS fits
Nationwide Payment Systems (NPS) publishes this guide. We are a payments company based in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, in business since 2001, and we sell merchant accounts and invoicing software, so we are not neutral. We offer interchange pass-through pricing, ACH, a payment gateway and Smart Invoicing, and we also offer flat-rate options. We do not publish a price list. The study we cite was written by our CEO. NPS offers a free statement review. Browse more in our payments guides.
Frequently asked questions
What should I compare in invoicing software that accepts credit cards and ACH?
Compare the total each package charges on your own month of paid invoices, split by how each invoice was paid. Put ten questions to every package in writing, covering the card price, the ACH price and any dollar cap, the monthly line, whether customers can choose card or ACH, how long each takes to reach your bank, what happens on returns, refunds and voids, what each dispute costs, extra lines, statement detail and the terms for leaving. Then total the month for each package with the same invoices.
How do I price card and ACH invoices on the same month?
Write down your invoices in size groups, then price each group for each way of paying with the method in Step 3. In the made-up month on this page, 50 invoices paid by card came to $989.50 on invented Package One and $952.90 on invented Package Two. With all 50 paid by ACH they came to $138.00 and $140.00. Those figures are invented and are not a promise.
Does the share of invoices paid by ACH change which package costs less?
In the made-up month, Package Two cost less through 4 ACH payments and Package One cost less from the 5th, when the largest invoices moved to ACH first. In these invented packages, the card fee that moves away grows with the invoice dollars, while an ACH fee that is capped or flat grows only with the count, so write down both shares from your own months before you compare.
Which Stripe lines apply to an invoice?
As read on Stripe’s pricing page on November 13, 2026, Invoicing is listed at 0.4% per paid invoice, a separate line lists +0.5% for manually entered cards, and the card line is 2.9% + 30 cents per successful domestic card transaction. Which of those lines apply to your invoice is a question for Stripe in writing, asked for an invoice paid each way your customers pay. Check the page for today’s price. We do not compare Stripe with other packages on this page.
What should I ask about disputes and refunds on invoices?
Ask whether the fee on a refunded invoice is returned and where that would show on the statement. Ask what each dispute costs at each stage and which amounts come back if you win. As read on Stripe’s pricing page on November 13, 2026, one received-and-answered dispute is $30 before any refund, and three are $90. Check the page for today’s price.
Does NPS offer a statement review?
Yes. NPS offers a free statement review.
Does the study say interchange pass-through costs less for invoices?
In the study’s model, interchange pass-through costs 19% to 31% less than flat rate for online and invoice sales across average tickets of $15 to $2,500, and flat rate can still win for very small tickets and for brand-new businesses with very low volume. The study is a cost model built from published rate schedules, not a survey, and it comes from a processor that sells pass-through pricing, so check it against your own invoices and your own written quote.





