Sometimes yes and sometimes no, and the answer depends on a few numbers you can pull from your own statement in ten minutes. Interchange plus is also called pass-through, and the model we cite finds it costs 19% to 31% less than flat rate for online and invoice sales. But a quote can carry fixed monthly fees too, and at low volume those can cancel the gain. This guide shows the break-even method with made-up math, when flat rate wins, and what to get in writing.
The short answer
- It depends on your quote, not on a magic volume. There is no official “$10,000 line.” Fixed monthly fees weigh more on a small monthly volume, so the same quote can lose at one volume and win at another.
- The model leans toward pass-through for online and invoice sales. NPS’s 2026 pricing study finds pass-through costs 19% to 31% less than flat rate for those sales across average tickets from $15 to $2,500. It is a model, not a survey, and it was written by a company that sells pass-through pricing, so we are not neutral.
- Flat rate can still win. The study says so for very small tickets (around $15 and under in person) and for brand-new businesses with very low volume.
- Our arithmetic: in the made-up example below, a $25 monthly fee puts the break-even near $7,800 a month. Your quote will have different numbers.
- The only way to know is a written quote and your own statement. NPS offers a free statement review, and you can also do the arithmetic yourself with the steps below.
What you are actually comparing
A flat-rate processor charges one headline price for a card payment. As read on Stripe’s pricing page on November 13, 2026, that price is 2.9% plus 30 cents per successful domestic card transaction. As read on Square’s fees page on November 13, 2026, Square lists 2.6% plus 15 cents for tap, dip or swipe, 3.3% plus 30 cents for online sales or invoices, and 3.5% plus 15 cents for manual entry or card on file. Prices change, so check each page for today’s price.
Flat-Rate Prices
What flat-rate processors charge per payment
- Stripe2.9% + 30¢Per successful domestic card transactionAs read on Stripe’s pricing page on November 13, 2026
- Square2.6% + 15¢Tap, dip or swipe3.3% + 30¢ for online sales or invoices; 3.5% + 15¢ for manual entry or card on file. As read on Square’s fees page on November 13, 2026
An interchange-plus quote should list its parts: interchange, which varies by card type, a markup, and any monthly or per-item fees. Ask the processor to write each one down. Our guide to where Stripe fees actually go shows the parts in more detail.
Pricing Models
Flat rate vs interchange plus: key differences
- How is the price set?
- Flat rateOne headline rate for every card
- Interchange plusInterchange + markup + fixed fees listed separately
- Very small tickets (around $15 and under, in person)?
- Flat rateCan still win here
- Interchange plusStudy says flat rate can still win
- Online and invoice sales?
- Flat rateRate does not change with card type
- Interchange plus19% to 31% less than flat rate in the model
- Low or brand-new volume?
- Flat rateCan still win; check for monthly fee
- Interchange plusFixed monthly fee can erase the saving
The only way to know is a written quote and your own statement.
So the question for a small business is not “which model is better.” It is “which total is lower for my sales, after every fixed fee.” That is why volume matters at all: a fixed monthly fee is the same $25 whether you process $2,000 or $20,000, while the saving on each dollar is small and grows with every dollar.
A break-even example, with made-up numbers
This is made-up math to show the method, not a promise. We invented an interchange-plus quote for a business that sells online at a $150 average ticket. Every number below except the flat-rate price is invented for the example, and your real quote will differ.
- Flat rate: Stripe’s listed 2.9% plus 30 cents per payment (as read on Stripe’s pricing page on November 13, 2026).
- Made-up interchange plus quote: an all-in card cost of 2.1% plus 12 cents (our invented blend of interchange and network fees), an invented markup of 0.5% plus 15 cents, and a made-up fixed fee of $25 a month.
We ran the arithmetic with python at four monthly volumes, all in $150 sales:
- $1,000 a month (about 7 payments): flat rate costs about $31.00. The made-up quote costs about $27.80 in variable fees plus the $25, so about $52.80. Flat rate is cheaper by about $22.
- $5,000 a month (about 33 payments): flat rate costs about $155.00. The quote costs about $139.00 plus $25, so about $164.00. Flat rate is cheaper by about $9.
- $8,000 a month (about 53 payments): flat rate costs about $248.00. The quote costs about $222.40 plus $25, so about $247.40. Nearly even, with the quote ahead by about 60 cents.
- $10,000 a month (about 67 payments): flat rate costs about $310.00. The quote costs about $278.00 plus $25, so about $303.00. The quote is cheaper by about $7 a month, or about $84 a year.
Made-Up Example
How costs compare at four monthly volumes
| Monthly volume | Flat-rate cost | Quote cost (variable + $25 fee) |
|---|---|---|
| $1,000 (~7 payments) | About $31.00 | About $52.80 to flat rate cheaper by ~$22 |
| $5,000 (~33 payments) | About $155.00 | About $164.00 to flat rate cheaper by ~$9 |
| $8,000 (~53 payments) | About $248.00 | About $247.40 to nearly even |
| $10,000 (~67 payments) | About $310.00 | About $303.00 to quote cheaper by ~$7/month |
The method behind the break-even is simple. First, find the saving on variable fees per dollar of volume. In the example it is about 0.32 cents per dollar (0.3 percentage points plus 3 cents on each $150 payment). Second, divide the fixed monthly fee by that saving: $25 divided by 0.0032 is roughly $7,800 a month. Below that, the fixed fee wins. Above it, the lower variable cost wins. Change the invented numbers and the answer moves.
Notice what drives the result. A lower fixed fee helps a lot. A higher markup hurts. This is why a headline like “interchange plus saves 20%” cannot tell you what you will save.
Why the study can show savings and your quote can still lose
The study, “The Flat-Rate Tax” (2026 Edition), was written by Allen Kopelman, the CEO of NPS. It is a model built from published rate schedules, not a survey. In the model, a business collecting $50,000 a month in invoices at a $150 average ticket keeps about $6,100 a year.
That example is at five times the top of this page’s range, and it is the study’s figure from its own inputs, not our finding and not a promise. At low volume, a percentage saving is a small number of dollars, so a fixed fee or minimum can erase it. That is the honest answer to the question in the title: the savings are real in the model, but they are small in dollars when volume is small.
When flat rate wins under $10,000 a month
Do not leave a simple setup just because pass-through is cheaper on paper. Flat rate can be the better choice when:
- You are brand new with very low volume. The study says flat rate can still win here. Check whether the flat-rate account you are offered has any monthly fee.
- Your tickets are very small and in person. The study says flat rate can still win at around $15 and under in person.
- Your volume swings a lot. If some months are close to nothing, a fixed monthly fee costs you in the quiet months. NPS has a post on flat rate versus interchange plus for a seasonal business.
- The quote you were given has a monthly minimum. A minimum can turn a low-volume month into a loss. Ask whether there is one.
For more on when flat pricing is the sensible pick, see is flat-rate processing ever the better deal.
When interchange plus is worth a look under $10,000
The case gets stronger when several of these are true at once:
- You sell online or by invoice. The study’s 19% to 31% figure is for online and invoice sales.
- Many customers pay with debit. Large-bank debit is capped (0.05% + 21 cents, plus a 1 cent fraud adjustment), and the flat-rate prices listed above do not change with the card type. The cap does NOT apply to small-bank debit, so read whether the debit cap applies to small-bank cards before you assume it does.
- Volume is growing. A quote that loses at $4,000 a month may win at $9,000. If you expect to cross the break-even soon, factor that in.
- The fixed fees are low and written down. This is the single biggest swing factor in the example above.
Business and commercial cards can cost more in interchange, and Level 2 and Level 3 data can lower them. If your customers are companies, pull a sample of paid invoices and check which kind of card they used before you estimate anything.
How to test it with your own numbers in ten minutes
- Pull three months of card sales. Note total dollars, number of payments and how the payments were taken (in person, online, invoice, keyed).
- Work out your average ticket and your effective rate. Effective rate is total fees divided by total dollars. Our guide to reading your merchant statement shows where each line lives.
- Get a written quote. Ask for the markup, the monthly fee, any gateway or statement fee, any PCI fee, any minimum and the contract length.
- Do the break-even. Estimate the variable fees under the quote, add the fixed fees, and compare with your current cost. Use your quarterly volume and not your best month.
- Ask what happens if you leave. A cancellation fee changes the math. Get it in writing.
Break-Even Method
Test your own numbers in ten minutes
-
Pull three months of card salesNote total dollars, number of payments and how the payments were taken (in person, online, invoice, keyed).
-
Work out your average ticket and your effective rateEffective rate is total fees divided by total dollars.
-
Get a written quoteAsk for the markup, the monthly fee, any gateway or statement fee, any PCI fee, any minimum and the contract length.
-
Do the break-evenEstimate the variable fees under the quote, add the fixed fees, and compare with your current cost.
-
Ask what happens if you leaveA cancellation fee changes the math.
The guide to cheapest payment processing in 2026 covers the wider comparison, and how much you are really paying on Stripe, Square, PayPal or QuickBooks walks the same exercise across providers.
Questions to ask before you switch
- What is the markup over interchange, in writing, and is it fixed for the whole term?
- What are the monthly, gateway, statement and PCI fees, and is there a minimum?
- What do keyed and card-on-file payments cost?
- What are the dispute fees, and are any refunded if I win?
- What does it cost to cancel, and is there a contract term?
- Can I see a sample statement that shows every fee on its own line?
Before You Switch
Questions to ask every processor in writing
- Ask for the markup over interchange, in writing, and confirm it is fixed for the whole term
- Ask for all monthly, gateway, statement and PCI fees, and whether there is a minimum
- Ask what keyed and card-on-file payments cost
- Ask for the dispute fees, and whether any are refunded if you win
- Ask what it costs to cancel, and whether there is a contract term
- Ask for a sample statement that shows every fee on its own line
If an answer is “it depends,” ask on what. A clear answer lets you do the arithmetic above yourself. If you sell by invoice, NPS also covers the topic in cheapest card processing for a service business using invoices and payment links. Restaurants can read the restaurant version, and shops that leave Square can read what a retail store saves leaving Square.
You can also run your own numbers through our savings calculator.
A one-page worksheet for your own break-even
Write these lines on a sheet of paper for one recent month. Line one: total card sales. Line two: the number of card payments. Line three: your average ticket, which is line one divided by line two. Line four: the total fees you paid on cards.
Line five is your current real rate, which is line four divided by line one. Keep it as a percentage and as dollars per month.
Now ask each processor you are comparing for a written quote. Copy its parts onto the sheet: the fixed cents on each payment, the percentage markup, any monthly fee, and any other fixed line. Ask the processor to confirm that the list is complete.
Work out what the quote would have cost on your own month. Multiply line three by the percentage parts, add the fixed cents times line two, and add the monthly fees. Subtract the result from line four. That is the monthly difference in dollars.
Repeat the sum at half your volume and at double your volume. A quote that wins at one volume can lose at another, and you will see where the break-even sits for your business.
If the monthly difference is small, ask whether a monthly fee can be lowered or removed, and ask how long the quoted terms last. Keep the written quote with the sheet so you can check your statements against it.
Who wrote this, and where NPS fits
Nationwide Payment Systems (NPS) publishes this guide. We are a payments company based in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, in business since 2001, and we sell merchant accounts and invoicing software, so we are not neutral. We offer interchange pass-through, ACH, a payment gateway and Smart Invoicing, and we also offer flat-rate options. We do not publish a price list. The study we cite was written by our CEO. NPS offers a free statement review. Browse more in our payments guides.
We are not the right fit for every business. If your volume is very low or brand new, a simple flat-rate account may cost you less, and we would rather you know that before you call.
Bottom line
Under $10,000 a month, interchange plus is worth it when your quote’s variable savings, over a full month of your own sales, are larger than its fixed fees. In our made-up example that happened near $7,800 a month, and it will happen somewhere else for your quote. Pull your own numbers, check each processor’s own pricing page for today’s price, and compare one written quote line by line. If you would like a second opinion, you can contact our team.
Frequently asked questions
Is interchange plus worth it under $10,000 a month?
It can be, but it is not automatic. The study’s model finds pass-through costs 19% to 31% less than flat rate for online and invoice sales, yet a quote with monthly fees can erase the gain at low volume. Compare your own statement against a written quote, line by line.
Where does the break-even point come from?
It comes from your quote, not from a rule. Divide the quote’s fixed monthly fees by the gap per dollar between flat rate and the quote’s variable cost. In our made-up example, a $25 monthly fee breaks even at about $7,800 a month. That is made-up math to show the method, not a promise.
Can flat rate still be the better choice at low volume?
Yes. The study says flat rate can still win for very small tickets (around $15 and under in person) and for brand-new businesses with very low volume.
What does flat rate cost on $5,000 a month?
Using Stripe’s listed 2.9% plus 30 cents, as read on its pricing page on November 13, 2026, $5,000 a month in $150 sales costs about $155 (our arithmetic: $145 plus about 33 payments at 30 cents). Check Stripe’s pricing page for today’s price.
Which fees should I ask about besides the markup?
Ask for the markup over interchange, any monthly, gateway or statement fee, any PCI fee, any minimum, the cost of keyed or card-on-file payments, dispute fees and the contract length. Ask for a sample statement that shows each fee on its own line.
Does the debit cap help a small business?
Only partly. Large-bank debit is capped (0.05% + 21 cents, plus a 1 cent fraud adjustment), but the cap does not apply to small-bank debit. Your own mix of cards decides how much it matters, so read your statement.
Does NPS offer a free statement review?
NPS offers a free statement review.





