What a merchant account for ecommerce costs is whatever a written quote adds up to on your own orders, so ask each provider for every line in writing. We cannot name a price for any merchant account provider, so this page shows how to work it out with made-up months. In the made-up interchange pass-through quote below, a store with $42 orders pays less on the flat 2.9% + 30 cents line through 119 orders a month and less on the quote from 120 orders. Those figures are invented to show the method. They are not a promise and not a price from any real provider. You repeat the same steps with your own last three months.
Flat rate vs. pass-through
Which option costs less depends on your order count
- Rate structure
- Flat 2.9% + 30¢2.9% + 30¢ per order, no monthly fee
- Invented pass-through quote2.45% + 28¢ per order, plus $25 a month
- 90 orders at $42 avg
- Flat 2.9% + 30¢$136.80 to cheaper by $6.10
- Invented pass-through quote$142.90 to more expensive
- 400 orders at $42 avg
- Flat 2.9% + 30¢$608.00 to more expensive
- Invented pass-through quote$549.00 to cheaper by $59.00
- Break-even at $42 avg order
- Flat 2.9% + 30¢Cheaper through 119 orders
- Invented pass-through quoteCheaper from 120 orders
Your own order count and average order value decide it.
Step 1: Write down your own month first
A quote means nothing until you have your own numbers beside it. For each of your last three months, write down three things: the number of orders paid, the dollars processed, and your average order value, which is the dollars divided by the orders. If your store is newer than three months, write down the months you have and mark the rest as missing.
How to compare quotes
Five steps to find your real processing cost
-
Write down your own month firstFor each of your last three months, write down the number of orders paid, the dollars processed, and your average order value.
-
Price the four months on a flat 2.9% + 30 cents lineEach order’s fee is the order’s dollars times 2.9% plus 30 cents, rounded to the cent (half up).
-
Price the same four months on an invented pass-through quotePrice each order at its dollars times 2.45% plus 28 cents, rounded to the cent the same way, then multiply by the orders and add $25.00.
-
Find the order count where the invented quote starts costing less than the flat lineThe break-even order count is $25 divided by the saving per order, and the first order count at which the quote is cheaper is the next whole order above that result.
-
Questions to put to a merchant account provider in writingPut each question to the provider, ask for the answer in writing, and write the answer in the cell for that line on your sheet.
The rest of this page uses four made-up stores, one invented month each, so that the order count and the average order value both move. None of them is a real store.
- Store A: 90 orders at an average of $42, which is $3,780 processed
- Store B: 400 orders at an average of $42, which is $16,800 processed
- Store C: 150 orders at an average of $180, which is $27,000 processed
- Store D: 1,200 orders at an average of $65, which is $78,000 processed
Stores A and B have the same average order value and very different order counts. Stores C and D differ in both. Write your own months in the same three columns before you read on.
See NPS’s page: “Merchant Account Cost Calculator: What to Plug In and How to Read the Result“.
Step 2: Price the four months on a flat 2.9% + 30 cents line
Start with the flat line, because it is the easiest to price and it gives you something to measure a merchant account quote against. As read on Stripe’s pricing page on November 13, 2026, Stripe lists 2.9% + 30 cents per successful domestic card transaction. Prices change, so open the page for today’s price. Here is our arithmetic, stated once for the whole page. Each order’s fee is the order’s dollars times 2.9% plus 30 cents, rounded to the cent (half up), and the month’s flat bill is that fee times the number of orders. A real statement can differ by a few cents. We computed every figure below with a script. At a $42 order the fee is $1.52 (2.9% of $42 is $1.218, plus 30 cents is $1.518). At a $65 order it is $2.19 ($2.185 rounded up). At a $180 order it is $5.52.
- Store A: 90 orders times $1.52 is $136.80, which is $3.62 per $100 processed ($3,780).
- Store B: 400 orders times $1.52 is $608.00, which is $3.62 per $100 ($16,800).
- Store C: 150 orders times $5.52 is $828.00, which is $3.07 per $100 ($27,000).
- Store D: 1,200 orders times $2.19 is $2,628.00, which is $3.37 per $100 ($78,000).
Made-up cost comparison
Flat rate wins small; pass-through wins at volume
- 90 orders, $42 avg$136.80Flat 2.9% + 30¢ (cheaper)Invented quote costs $142.90 to flat line wins through 119 orders a month
- 400 orders, $42 avg$549.00Invented quote (cheaper)Flat line costs $608.00 to invented quote wins from 120 orders a month
- 1,200 orders, $65 avg$2,269.00Invented quote (cheaper)Flat line costs $2,628.00 to a difference of $359.00
Made-up store examples
Order count and average order value both move the cost
| Store (invented) | Orders & avg order value | Flat-rate cost per $100 |
|---|---|---|
| Store A | 90 orders at $42 avg | $3.62 per $100 |
| Store B | 400 orders at $42 avg | $3.62 per $100 |
| Store C | 150 orders at $180 avg | $3.07 per $100 |
| Store D | 1,200 orders at $65 avg | $3.37 per $100 |
Look at Stores A and B. They have the same cost per $100, $3.62, even though one has 90 orders and the other has 400. In our arithmetic the flat line has no monthly part, so two months with the same average order value land on the same cost per $100. Only a change in the average order value moves it, which is why Store C at $180 comes out lower at $3.07 and Store D at $65 comes out at $3.37. To check your own months, divide the total fees you paid in a month by the total dollars processed in the same month, then multiply by 100.
Disputes get their own row on the sheet, and so do refunds. Stripe’s pricing page, as read on November 13, 2026, lists disputes at $15.00 for each dispute received, $15.00 for each dispute you respond to manually (refunded for won disputes) and $15.00 for each dispute appealed (not refunded). One dispute that is received and answered by hand is $30 before any refund, and three of them are $90. Say Store B had three of those in its month. Write $90.00 in a row of its own, below the $608.00 row. Then ask of every quote you collect what it says about disputes and refunds. If you use a different provider today, write what its page lists on the same rows.
See NPS’s page: “Is Flat-Rate Processing Ever the Better Deal? When 2.9% + 30 Cents Wins“.
Step 3: Price the same four months on an invented pass-through quote
Now take an invented quote with the card cost on one line and the provider’s markup on another. Everything in this quote is invented. We made up a card cost of 1.90% + 10 cents per order, a markup of 0.55% + 18 cents per order, and a $25 monthly line. Together that is 2.45% + 28 cents per order, plus $25 a month. Those numbers are not from any real provider. Replace the invented card cost with the real one from your own statements when you have it.
Price each order at its dollars times 2.45% plus 28 cents, rounded to the cent the same way. That is $1.31 at a $42 order (1.029 plus 0.28 is 1.309), $1.87 at a $65 order (1.5925 plus 0.28 is 1.8725) and $4.69 at a $180 order. Then multiply by the orders and add $25.00.
- Store A: 90 orders times $1.31 is $117.90, plus $25.00 is $142.90, which is $3.78 per $100.
- Store B: 400 orders times $1.31 is $524.00, plus $25.00 is $549.00, which is $3.27 per $100.
- Store C: 150 orders times $4.69 is $703.50, plus $25.00 is $728.50, which is $2.70 per $100.
- Store D: 1,200 orders times $1.87 is $2,244.00, plus $25.00 is $2,269.00, which is $2.91 per $100.
Put the two columns side by side, the same dollars and the same orders in each. Store A pays $136.80 on the flat line and $142.90 on the invented quote, so the flat line is cheaper by $6.10. Store B pays $608.00 against $549.00, so the invented quote is cheaper by $59.00. Store C pays $828.00 against $728.50, a difference of $99.50. Store D pays $2,628.00 against $2,269.00, a difference of $359.00.
Store A’s 90 orders cost $117.90 in per-order fees on the invented quote, less than its $136.80 flat bill. The $25 monthly line is what turns that around.
See NPS’s page: “How Average Ticket Size Changes Your Real Processing Rate“.
Step 4: Find the order count where the invented quote starts costing less than the flat line
This is the number the page builds to: the orders a month at which the invented quote starts costing less than the flat line. Each order saves a little against the flat line in this invented quote: the flat fee minus the quote fee, each rounded to the cent. The $25 line has to be earned back out of those savings. So the break-even order count is $25 divided by the saving per order, and the first order count at which the quote is cheaper is the next whole order above that result.
- At a $42 average order: the saving per order is $1.52 minus $1.31, which is 21 cents, and $25 divided by 21 cents is about 119.05. At 119 orders the flat line is cheaper by 1 cent ($180.88 against $180.89). At 120 orders the invented quote is cheaper by 20 cents ($182.40 against $182.20). The flat line is cheaper through 119 orders and the quote is cheaper from 120.
- At a $65 average order: the saving per order is $2.19 minus $1.87, which is 32 cents, and $25 divided by 32 cents is about 78.1. The two never cost exactly the same. At 78 orders the flat line is cheaper by 4 cents ($170.82 against $170.86). At 79 orders the invented quote is cheaper by 28 cents ($173.01 against $172.73). The quote is cheaper from 79 orders.
- At a $180 average order: the saving per order is $5.52 minus $4.69, which is 83 cents, and $25 divided by 83 cents is about 30.1. At 30 orders the flat line is cheaper by 10 cents ($165.60 against $165.70). At 31 orders the invented quote is cheaper by 73 cents ($171.12 on the flat line against $170.39 on the quote). The quote is cheaper from 31 orders.
In this invented quote, the break-even order count falls as the average order value rises, because each order saves more. It also moves when the monthly line moves. At a $42 average order, a made-up $10 monthly line makes the quote cheaper from 48 orders, and a made-up $40 monthly line makes it cheaper from 191 orders. Ask any quote for its monthly lines in writing, then run the same arithmetic with your own average order value.
NPS’s 2026 pricing study is a cost model built from published rate schedules, not a survey. It says flat rate can still win for very small tickets and for brand-new businesses with very low volume. It also says interchange pass-through costs 19% to 31% less than flat rate for online and invoice sales across average tickets from $15 to $2,500. We sell pass-through pricing, so we are not neutral, and the study is our CEO’s work. Test it on your own months before you believe any of it.
Square’s fees page, as read on November 13, 2026, lists four lines: tap, dip or swipe at 2.6% + 15 cents, online sales or invoices at 3.3% + 30 cents, the online API at 2.9% + 30 cents, and manual entry or card on file at 3.5% + 15 cents. The Square figures here are for the Free plan. Square also lists paid plans (Plus and Premium) with different rates on its fees page, so check which plan your account is on. Ask which of Square’s lines your own checkout runs through. Here is Store E, a separate invented store that appears nowhere else on this page: 60 orders at an average of $95, which is $5,700 processed. On Square’s online sales or invoices line alone, the fee on a $95 order is $3.44 (3.3% of $95 is $3.135, plus 30 cents is $3.435, rounded up), so 60 orders times $3.44 is $206.40, or $3.62 per $100. We set no other price beside it.
See NPS’s page: “Cheapest way for an ecommerce store to take payments instead of Shopify Payments or Stripe“.
Step 5: Questions to put to a merchant account provider in writing
This part is questions only. We are not stating what any provider does, and nothing here is legal advice. Put each question to the provider, ask for the answer in writing, and write the answer in the cell for that line on your sheet. If the provider will not answer, write that down too.
- What is the percentage on each online order, and how many cents are added to each order?
- Is the quote an interchange pass-through quote, and if so, does it show the card cost for each order and your markup on separate lines?
- How do business and commercial cards appear on the quote and on the statement, given that business and commercial cards can cost more?
- Level 2 and Level 3 data can lower interchange. Can your checkout send that data, and would the quote show the difference?
- Is there a monthly fee, a statement fee, a gateway fee or a compliance fee, and what does each add up to over a year?
- Is there a monthly minimum, and which number does it apply to?
- If I refund an order, are the fees on that order returned, and where would I see it in writing?
- What does each dispute cost at each stage, and which of those amounts come back if I win?
- How does the account connect to my store platform, and does my platform add anything if I use an outside provider?
- How often are funds paid out to me, and is there any fee for a payout?
- Which of these lines can change during the term, and what notice do I get in writing?
Questions for providers
Ask every provider these questions in writing
- Ask for the percentage and cents added to each online order
- Ask whether the quote shows card cost and markup on separate lines
- Ask how business and commercial cards appear on the quote and statement
- Ask whether the checkout can send Level 2 and Level 3 data
- Ask for every monthly, statement, gateway and compliance fee totaled over a year
- Ask what each dispute costs at each stage and which amounts come back if you win
Take the answers back to your sheet and price your three months again with every line in. Compare any second quote on the same three months, line for line, a flat price with a flat price or a pass-through quote with a pass-through quote. Then run Step 4 once more with the answers you got.
See NPS’s page: “Cheaper Alternatives to Shopify Payments for a Growing Online Store“.
See NPS’s page: “Cheapest Payment Processing in 2026: What You Really Pay and How to Compare“.
Bottom line
What a merchant account for ecommerce costs is the total of its written lines on your own months. In the made-up example the flat 2.9% + 30 cents line cost $3.62 per $100 for a $42 average order, and the invented pass-through quote cost $3.78 per $100 in a 90-order month and $3.27 per $100 in a 400-order month. The break-even is where the invented quote starts costing less than the flat line. At a $42 average order the flat line is cheaper through 119 orders and the quote is cheaper from 120. To see your own result, write down orders, dollars processed and average order value for three months, price each month on every quote, and find the order count where the quote starts costing less than the flat line. Then ask each provider in writing for the lines that were missing.
You can also run your own numbers through our savings calculator.
Who wrote this, and where NPS fits
Nationwide Payment Systems (NPS) publishes this guide. We are a payments company based in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, in business since 2001, and we sell merchant accounts and invoicing software, so we are not neutral. We offer interchange pass-through pricing, ACH, a payment gateway and Smart Invoicing, and we also offer flat-rate options. We do not publish a price list. The study we cite was written by our CEO. NPS offers a free statement review. Browse more in our payments guides.
Frequently asked questions
What does a merchant account for ecommerce cost?
The cost is whatever a written quote adds up to on your own orders, so ask each provider for every line in writing. We cannot name a price for any merchant account provider. In our made-up example, an invented quote of 2.45% + 28 cents per order plus a $25 monthly line cost $549.00 on 400 orders of $42, which is $3.27 per $100. That is made-up math to show the method, not a promise.
When does a flat rate still win for an online store?
In our made-up example, the flat 2.9% + 30 cents line won in a month of 90 orders at a $42 average, because the invented quote’s $25 monthly line was spread over too few dollars. The flat line cost $136.80 and the invented quote cost $142.90. At a $42 average order the flat line is cheaper through 119 orders a month and the invented quote is cheaper from 120. The study also says flat rate can win for very small tickets and for brand-new businesses with very low volume. Your own order count and average order value decide it.
How do I find the break-even order count for my store?
Subtract the quote’s per-order fee from the flat line’s per-order fee at your average order value, each rounded to the cent, then divide the quote’s monthly line by that saving and go up to the next whole order. In the made-up example the saving at a $42 average order is 21 cents, so $25 divided by 21 cents is about 119.05, and the quote first costs less at 120 orders a month. Use your own average order value and the monthly lines the provider gives you in writing.
What should I ask about refunds and disputes?
Ask whether the fees on a refunded order are returned and where that would show in writing. Ask what each dispute costs at each stage and which amounts come back if you win. As read on Stripe’s pricing page on November 13, 2026, one received-and-answered dispute is $30 before any refund, and three are $90. Check the page for today’s price.
Does NPS offer a statement review?
Yes. NPS offers a free statement review.
Does the study say interchange pass-through would cost my store less?
The study says so for the average tickets in its model, not for your store. It is a cost model built from published rate schedules, not a survey, and it comes from a processor that sells pass-through pricing. In the model, interchange pass-through costs 19% to 31% less than flat rate for online and invoice sales across average tickets of $15 to $2,500, and one example is $50,000 a month in invoices at a $150 average ticket, which keeps about $6,100 a year. Your result depends on your own orders and your own quote.
Which Square line applies to my online orders?
Square’s fees page, as read on November 13, 2026, lists four lines: tap, dip or swipe at 2.6% + 15 cents, online sales or invoices at 3.3% + 30 cents, the online API at 2.9% + 30 cents, and manual entry or card on file at 3.5% + 15 cents. The Square figures here are for the Free plan. Square also lists paid plans (Plus and Premium) with different rates on its fees page, so check which plan your account is on. The two lines with online in their names are online sales or invoices and the online API. Ask Square in writing which line your checkout runs through, then check that line against your own statement.





