Why would a quote charge the same percentage on a debit card as on a premium credit card? In the made-up ledger on this page, the answer is that the quote names one percentage and a fixed number of cents for a payment and lists no card type, so the price does not move when the card behind the payment costs less or more. Interchange varies by card type, which means the distance between what a payment is quoted at and what its card costs is different for every card. This page measures that distance on a made-up $100 payment, runs two invented shops with different card mixes through the same quote, prices Square’s own four lines on one $100 payment, and ends with the questions to put to a provider. We sell interchange pass-through pricing, so we are not neutral. Every dollar figure below that is not on a processor’s own page is invented or our arithmetic, and we say which.

What does one made-up $100 payment cost on five card types?

This ledger is made-up math to show the method, not a promise and not a quote. We invented one flat quote, 2.50% + 20 cents, which is $2.70 on a $100 payment. We then listed five card types and put a card-side cost on each one. Only one of the five costs comes from a rule. Large-bank debit is capped at 0.05% + 21 cents plus 1 cent, which is $0.27 on $100 in our arithmetic. The other four card costs are invented, and your own cards will cost what they cost.

  • Large-bank debit: $0.27 card-side cost (the cap, our arithmetic, interchange only). Quoted at $2.70, so the gap is $2.43.
  • Small-bank debit: $0.95 card-side cost (invented). The cap does not apply to small-bank debit. The gap is $1.75.
  • Standard credit card: $1.60 card-side cost (invented). The gap is $1.10.
  • Premium credit card: $2.40 card-side cost (invented). The gap is $0.30.
  • Business or commercial card: $2.60 card-side cost (invented). Business and commercial cards can cost more, so we placed it highest. The gap is $0.10.

In this ledger, the gap is the quoted price minus the card-side cost. It is not profit. It also has to cover network fees and the provider’s own costs, which we do not price here, and we do not know what either would be on your account.

Now read down the gap column. The quote is the same $2.70 on every row, so the gap gets smaller as the card gets costlier. On the large-bank debit row the quote sits $2.43 above the card cost. On the premium credit row it sits $0.30 above. That is the title question in arithmetic. The quote does not look at the card, so the cheapest card in the ledger carries the widest gap and the costliest card carries the narrowest.

Put these questions to every provider you are considering, and ask for the answers in writing.

  • Does the quote list any card type on its own line, or is it one percentage and one fixed amount for the payment?
  • If a line lists card types, which ones, and what does each cost?
  • Where would a debit card and a premium credit card show up as different lines on my statement?
  • What is included in the one price, and what is billed on top of it?
  • Do business and commercial cards have their own line, and what does that line say?

Ask every provider

Questions to put to a provider in writing

  • Ask whether the quote lists any card type on its own line, or is it one percentage and one fixed amount.
  • Ask which card types are listed and what each one costs.
  • Ask where a debit card and a premium credit card would show up as different lines on your statement.
  • Ask what is included in the one price and what is billed on top of it.
  • Ask whether business and commercial cards have their own line and what that line says.
  • Ask for the card-side cost, the markup, the network fees and every monthly fee in writing.

If the answer to the first question is one percentage and one fixed amount, the ledger above is the picture to hold in mind. If the answer is a list of card types, ask for each price and put them next to your own card counts.

See NPS’s page: “Cheapest Payment Processing in 2026: What You Really Pay and How to Compare“.

Which of two made-up shops carries the wider gap?

Here are two invented shops. Each runs 100 payments of $100 in a month, which is $10,000 processed, and each is quoted the same 2.50% + 20 cents, so each is quoted $270.00. The only difference is the mix of cards. This is made-up math to show the method, not a promise.

  • Shop A (invented mix): 55 large-bank debit, 15 small-bank debit, 20 standard credit, 8 premium credit and 2 business payments.
  • Shop B (invented mix): 10 large-bank debit, 5 small-bank debit, 30 standard credit, 45 premium credit and 10 business payments.

Price each shop’s cards at the ledger costs from the section above. Shop A’s card-side costs are $14.85 + $14.25 + $32.00 + $19.20 + $5.20 = $85.50. Shop B’s are $2.70 + $4.75 + $48.00 + $108.00 + $26.00 = $189.45. Subtract each from the $270.00 quote and the gaps are $184.50 for Shop A and $80.55 for Shop B.

Same quote, same $10,000, same $270.00. The cards underneath cost $85.50 in one month and $189.45 in the other. The quote did not change between the two shops. The card costs did. In this made-up month, the quote sits $184.50 above Shop A’s card costs and $80.55 above Shop B’s.

Two invented shops

Same quote, very different card costs underneath

Card mix
Shop A (debit-heavy mix)55 large-bank debit, 8 premium credit, 2 business
Shop B (premium-heavy mix)10 large-bank debit, 45 premium credit, 10 business
Card-side costs
Shop A (debit-heavy mix)$85.50 for the month
Shop B (premium-heavy mix)$189.45 for the month
Gap to $270.00 quote
Shop A (debit-heavy mix)$184.50 above card costs
Shop B (premium-heavy mix)$80.55 above card costs

Same quote, same $10,000, same $270.00. The cards underneath cost $85.50 in one month and $189.45 in the other.

This is made-up math to show the method, not a promise.

If your own cards look like Shop A’s, the same arithmetic would show a wide gap, and if they look like Shop B’s, a narrow one. We do not know your mix. Your statement or a report from your provider can show it, so ask these before you compare any price.

  • Can I get one month of my payments sorted by card type, with a count and a dollar total for each?
  • What share of my payments is debit, and what share of that debit comes from small banks?
  • If the report cannot be sorted by card type, why not, and who can tell me?
  • Did my mix change between the last three months?

Do the sorting for three months in a row if you can, so you can see whether your mix holds still. The page below covers the debit share question in its own right.

See NPS’s page: “I Take Mostly Debit Cards: Is Flat Rate Processing Costing Me More Than Interchange Plus?“.

What would a quote that follows the card add up to?

To show the method on a quote that follows the card, we invented an interchange pass-through quote: the card-side cost of each payment plus a markup of 0.55% + 12 cents, which is $0.67 on a $100 payment. The markup is invented. It is not NPS’s markup and not any processor’s, and we state no real markup anywhere on this page.

Over 100 payments, $0.67 comes to $67.00. Add it to each shop’s card-side cost and the pass-through side is $85.50 + $67.00 = $152.50 for Shop A and $189.45 + $67.00 = $256.45 for Shop B. Against the $270.00 flat quote, that is $117.50 lower for Shop A and $13.55 lower for Shop B.

Do not read $117.50 or $13.55 as a saving. We left network fees and the provider’s own costs off the pass-through side, so the two totals are not yet like for like. Adding them would shrink each difference. The method is the point, and the two shops show why the answer changes with the card mix.

Now turn the question around. What markup would make the two sides equal in each made-up month? For Shop A it is $184.50 across the 100 payments. For Shop B it is $80.55. Those are the gap figures from the section above, and they have a plain use. For pass-through to come out lower in that month, the markup plus the network fees plus any monthly fee has to stay below the gap. Ask any pass-through quote for its markup in writing, and multiply it across your own month.

Here are the steps to run on your own numbers.

  1. Take one month of statements and count the payments by card type, with a dollar total for each.
  2. Ask each provider for the card-side cost of each count, in writing.
  3. Add the markup, the network fees and every monthly fee the quote lists.
  4. Divide the total fees you paid in a month by the total dollars processed in the same month, and write it down for the plan you have today.
  5. Compare the month’s total fees from each quote, not the headline rates.

Run your own numbers

Five steps to compare any quote on your own month

  1. Count payments by card typeTake one month of statements and count the payments by card type, with a dollar total for each.
  2. Ask for card-side costs in writingAsk each provider for the card-side cost of each count, in writing.
  3. Add all feesAdd the markup, the network fees and every monthly fee the quote lists.
  4. Find your effective rateDivide the total fees you paid in a month by the total dollars processed in the same month, and write it down for the plan you have today.
  5. Compare month totals, not headline ratesCompare the month’s total fees from each quote, not the headline rates.
Ask for the card-side cost, the markup, the network fees and every monthly fee in writing, then add them for your own last month.

See NPS’s page: “How Much Do Debit Cards Cost a Small Business Under Flat Rate vs Pass-Through Pricing?“.

Which of Square’s lines would each payment land on?

Square’s fees page (squareup.com/help/us/en/article/5068-square-fees-overview), as read on November 13, 2026, lists four lines, each named for how a payment is taken. Tap, dip or swipe is 2.6% + 15 cents. Online or invoices is 3.3% + 30 cents. Online API is 2.9% + 30 cents. Manual entry or card on file is 3.5% + 15 cents. The Square figures here are for the Free plan. Square also lists paid plans (Plus and Premium) with different rates on its fees page, so check which plan your account is on. Prices change, so open Square’s own page for today’s price before you use any figure here.

We price Square on Square alone and do not compare it with another processor. On one $100 payment, our arithmetic gives these results.

  • Tap, dip or swipe at 2.6% + 15 cents: $2.75.
  • Online or invoices at 3.3% + 30 cents: $3.60.
  • Online API at 2.9% + 30 cents: $3.20.
  • Manual entry or card on file at 3.5% + 15 cents: $3.65.

Square Free plan

Square’s four lines cost differently on one $100 payment

How payment is taken Rate Cost on $100
Tap, dip or swipe 2.6% + 15 cents $2.75
Online or invoices 3.3% + 30 cents $3.60
Online API 2.9% + 30 cents $3.20
Manual entry or card on file 3.5% + 15 cents $3.65

Inside Square, the gap between two of these lines is large enough to see on a single payment. A $100 payment on the manual entry or card on file line costs $0.90 more than the same $100 on the tap, dip or swipe line, and a $100 payment on the online or invoices line costs $0.85 more. Those are like-for-like comparisons between two Square lines.

None of the four line names mentions a card type. So ask a different question than the one in the title. For the payments you take, which line does a debit card land on, which line does a premium credit card land on, and are they the same line? If you take a debit card by tap and a premium credit card by typing in the number, the two payments could land on different lines for reasons that have nothing to do with the cards. Ask whichever provider you use, in writing, whether any line changes with the card type.

To check this on your own statement, sort one month by how each payment was taken and by card type, side by side, and ask whether a price difference comes from the card or from the way it was taken. The statement guide below shows where to look.

See NPS’s page: “How to Read Your Merchant Statement and understand how much you are paying!“.

What does the study say about debit and flat rate, and what does it leave out?

The study we cite, “The Flat-Rate Tax” (2026 Edition), was written by Allen Kopelman, the CEO of NPS. It is a cost model built from published rate schedules, not a survey, and NPS sells interchange pass-through pricing, so we are not neutral about its result. In the model, interchange pass-through costs 19% to 31% less than flat rate for online and invoice sales across average tickets from $15 to $2,500. One example from it is a business with $50,000 a month in invoices at a $150 average ticket, which keeps about $6,100 a year. You can read it as NPS’s 2026 pricing study.

That figure is for online and invoice sales. It is not a figure for walk-up sales and not for your account. The two shops above show that the same flat quote can sit far above or fairly close to the cost of the cards underneath, so your result depends on your own mix and quote.

The study also lists reasons a flat rate can still be the better fit. Flat rate can still win for very small tickets, around $15 and under in person, and for brand-new, very low-volume businesses. If either describes you, put a flat quote through the same written comparison on your own numbers.

Four details can move any comparison, and the ledger on this page does not price them.

  • Interchange varies by card type, so a mix like Shop A’s and a mix like Shop B’s do not cost the same to accept.
  • Large-bank debit is capped at 0.05% + 21 cents plus 1 cent, and the cap does not apply to small-bank debit.
  • Business and commercial cards can cost more.
  • Level 2 and Level 3 data can lower interchange. Ask any provider whether your payments can carry it and what the quote says about it.

Ask for the card-side cost, the markup, the network fees and every monthly fee in writing, then add them for your own last month. A quote that only shows a headline rate has not answered the question.

See NPS’s page: “Does the Debit Interchange Cap Apply to Small-Bank Debit Cards?“.

Bottom line

A flat quote charges the same on a debit card as on a premium credit card because it names one percentage and a fixed number of cents and lists no card type. In our made-up ledger the quote sat $2.43 above the cost of a large-bank debit card and $0.30 above the cost of a premium credit card, and two invented shops with different mixes were quoted the same $270.00 for cards that cost $85.50 and $189.45. To find out where you stand, sort one month by card type, ask each provider for the card-side cost, markup, network fees and monthly fees in writing, and compare the month’s total. Use the questions in this page, and read the numbers as method, not as a promise.

You can also run your own numbers through our savings calculator.

Who wrote this, and where NPS fits

Nationwide Payment Systems (NPS) publishes this guide. We are a payments company based in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, in business since 2001, and we sell merchant accounts and invoicing software, so we are not neutral. We offer interchange pass-through pricing, ACH, a payment gateway and Smart Invoicing, and we also offer flat-rate options. We do not publish a price list. The study we cite was written by our CEO. NPS offers a free statement review. Browse more in our payments guides.

Frequently asked questions

Why does flat rate processing charge the same percentage on a debit card as on a premium credit card?

The quote names one percentage and a fixed number of cents and lists no card type, so the price does not change with the card. In our made-up ledger, the same $2.70 quote sat $2.43 above a large-bank debit card’s cost and $0.30 above an invented premium credit card’s cost. Ask any provider whether its quote lists card types on separate lines.

Which card mix carries the wider gap under a flat quote?

In our made-up month, the debit-heavy shop’s $270.00 quote sat $184.50 above its card costs of $85.50, and the premium-heavy shop’s sat $80.55 above its card costs of $189.45. Those mixes and costs are invented to show the method, so sort your own month by card type to see yours.

Does the debit interchange cap apply to every debit card?

No. Large-bank debit is capped at 0.05% + 21 cents plus 1 cent, and the cap does not apply to small-bank debit. Ask your provider for a report that shows how much of your debit comes from each.

How do I find my effective rate?

Divide the total fees you paid in a month by the total dollars processed in the same month. Do it for each of the last three months, then sort each month by card type so you can see where the fees came from.

What should I ask a provider about card types?

Ask whether the quote lists any card type on its own line, which card types are listed, what each one costs, and what is billed on top of the one price. Ask for the answers in writing, and ask for the total your last month’s counts would have produced.

What does NPS’s 2026 pricing study say?

It is a cost model built from published rate schedules, not a survey. In the model, interchange pass-through costs 19% to 31% less than flat rate for online and invoice sales across average tickets from $15 to $2,500, and NPS sells pass-through, so we are not neutral. Flat rate can still win for very small tickets, around $15 and under in person, and for brand-new, very low-volume businesses.

Does NPS offer a statement review?

Yes. NPS offers a free statement review.