Why High-Risk and High-Volume Businesses Need More Than One Merchant Account
If your business operates in a high-risk industry or processes a high volume of transactions each month, relying on just one merchant account, especially with a provider like Stripe, it could be a costly mistake. Many business owners do not realize how vulnerable they are until it is too late.
Here is the hard truth: If your primary merchant account gets shut down and you do not have a backup, you could be out of business for days, weeks, or even permanently. Therefore, having a multi-merchant account strategy for high-risk businesses is essential.
sponsored by
The Risks of Relying on a Single Merchant Account
Payment processors, particularly ones like Stripe, have strict risk management policies. While they make it easy to set up an account, they often do not conduct thorough underwriting upfront. Instead, they review your business more closely once you hit a certain volume or a flagged transaction pattern. At that point, they may:
Freeze your funds – Your revenue could be locked up for months, leaving you without cash flow.
Shut down your account – If your merchant account is terminated, you will have no way to process payments.
Blacklist your business – Some processors may even prevent you from opening another account in the future. They will not reopen your accounts.
Match List – worst case scenario and you cannot process cards for 5 years or longer.
The Problem with Waiting Until It is Too Late
If your account gets shut down, pivoting to another payment processor is not instant. Setting up a new merchant account, especially if you require custom integration, can take days or weeks. If you are handling millions of dollars in transactions each month, that kind of downtime can be devastating. This highlights why a strategy for high-risk businesses should always include multiple merchant accounts.
We have spoken to countless merchants who did not have a contingency plan, only to find themselves scrambling when their payment processor unexpectedly shut them down. Without a backup, you risk losing revenue, customers, and even your business itself.
The Solution: A Multi-Merchant Account Strategy
The best way to protect your business is to have multiple merchant accounts in place before you need them. This means:
Diversifying your payment processors – Don't put all your transactions through one provider. Instead, allocate at least 20% of your volume to a secondary merchant account. You can use certain gateways that do load balancing or you can use other methods with API’s to connect to your site.
Choosing providers that conduct full underwriting upfront – Unlike Stripe, traditional merchant service providers approve you before you start processing, reducing the risk of sudden shutdowns.
Setting up integrations in advance – If your business relies on custom payment processing, integrating your backup provider before you need it will save you time and stress later.
Having a crisis plan – If a shutdown happens, you should be able to switch to your backup account immediately. Just let the provider know you are going to be sending over more volume.
Get a Backup Plan Before You Need One
Many businesses wait until they are in trouble to seek out a new merchant account—but by then, it is often too late. A proactive approach, such as adopting a strategy for high-risk businesses, can save your business from disruption, lost revenue, and financial disaster.
At Nationwide Payment Systems, we help businesses navigate these challenges and set up reliable, scalable payment solutions before problems arise. If you process high-risk or high-volume transactions, do not wait for a crisis—get your strategy for high-risk businesses in place today.
CLICK HERE TO FIND MORE ABOUT OUR PROGRAMS
FAQ: Frequently Asked Questions
Why do high-risk businesses need more than one merchant account?
High-risk businesses are more likely to face sudden account shutdowns, fund holds, or restrictions from payment processors like Stripe. Having multiple merchant accounts ensures that if one provider suspends your account, you can continue processing payments without major disruptions.
How much of my payment volume should go through a secondary merchant account?
A good rule of thumb is to send at least 20% of your transactionsthrough a secondary merchant account. This ensures that your backup account remains active and ready in case your primary processor shuts down.
How long does it take to get a new merchant account if my current one is shut down?
Setting up a new merchant account can take days or even weeks, depending on the provider, your industry, and the complexity of your payment processing needs. If you require custom integrations, the process can take even longer making it essential to have a backup in place before you need it.
How is a traditional merchant account different from Stripe or PayPal?
Unlike Stripe or PayPal, traditional merchant service providers conduct full underwriting upfront, which reduces the risk of sudden account terminations. Stripe and PayPal often allow businesses to start processing right away but review accounts more closely only after they hit certain thresholds—leading to unexpected shutdowns.
What industries are considered high-risk by payment processors?
High-risk industries include CBD, adult entertainment, travel, subscription services, firearms, high-ticket coaching, and financial services, among others. These businesses face a higher likelihood of chargebacks, fraud, or regulatory scrutiny, making them more vulnerable to account for shutdowns.
